Loading more restaurants...
Pizza in Shelter Island, NY
2 pizza restaurants
📍 Nearby Cities
🍴 Cuisines
All Cuisines
🍔
American
4
Pizza
2
Sandwiches
2
Italian
2
Seafood
2
Ice Cream
1
Yogurt
1
Barbecue
1
Australian
1
Breakfast
1
Diner
1
Mexican
1
Bar
1
Asian Fusion
1
American New
1
Gastropubs
1
Bakery
1
Breweries
1
Bagels
1
Bar Food
1
Cafe
1
Seafood Markets
1
Chinese
1
Pizza Restaurants
Showing 2 of 2
Ad Space (728x90 Leaderboard)
✨ You've seen all 2 restaurants!
Explore More
🏙️
All Shelter Island Restaurants
Browse everything in this city
📍
New York Restaurants
Explore the whole state