Ice Cream in Shelter Island, NY

All Cuisines

🍔

American

4

🍕

Pizza

2

🥪

Sandwiches

2

🍝

Italian

2

🦞

Seafood

2

🍦

Ice Cream

1

🥛

Yogurt

1

🍖

Barbecue

1

🦘

Australian

1

🥞

Breakfast

1

🍔

Diner

1

🌮

Mexican

1

🍺

Bar

1

🍜

Asian Fusion

1

🍽️

American New

1

🍺

Gastropubs

1

🥐

Bakery

1

🍺

Breweries

1

🥯

Bagels

1

🍺

Bar Food

1

☕

Cafe

1

🦞

Seafood Markets

1

🥡

Chinese

1