Loading more restaurants...

Eagle Bay, NY

Discover 12 local restaurants

📍 Nearby Cities

🍴 Cuisines

12 Restaurants in Eagle Bay

Showing 12 of 12

Eagle Bay Restaurants

12 of 12

The Bay Cafe and Market

American

4.8 ★★★★★

• $$ • 📋 Menu

5560 State Route 28

Eagle Bay, NY 13331

📞 (315) 882-7196 🌐 Website

Bay Cafe

Subs

4.0 ★★★★☆

• $$ • 📋 Menu

5556 Hwy 28

Eagle Bay, NY 13331

📞 (315) 357-2613 🌐 Website

Glenmore Bar & Grill

Bar Food

4.8 ★★★★★

• $$ • 📋 Menu

146 Glenmore Rd

Eagle Bay, NY 13331

📞 (315) 357-4891 🌐 Website

The Little Fox

Bar

4.8 ★★★★★

• $$ • 📋 Menu

1910 Big Moose Rd

Eagle Bay, NY 13331

📞 (315) 357-6000 🌐 Website

Northern Lights

Ice Cream

4.3 ★★★★☆

• $ • 📋 Menu

162 Rte 28

Eagle Bay, NY 13331

📞 (315) 357-2274

Big Moose Station

American

4.1 ★★★★☆

• $$ • 📋 Menu

Big Moose Rd

Eagle Bay, NY 13331

📞 (315) 357-3525 🌐 Website

The Eagle Bay House

Pasta

4.5 ★★★★★

• $$ • 📋 Menu

5521 NY-28

Eagle Bay, NY 13331

📞 (315) 390-4101

Lanterns

American

5.0 ★★★★★

• $$ • 📋 Menu

Route 28

Eagle Bay, NY 13331

📞 (315) 357-5461

The Donut Shop

Coffee Shop

4.4 ★★★★☆

• $ • 📋 Menu

5474 State Rte 28

Eagle Bay, NY 13331

📞 (315) 357-6421 🌐 Website

Twister's Ice Cream

Ice Cream

5.0 ★★★★★

• $$$$ • 📋 Menu

5556 State Rt 28

Eagle Bay, NY 13331

📞 (315) 357-2613

The Toboggan Inn

Bar

4.5 ★★★★★

• $$ • 📋 Menu

5521 New York 28

Eagle Bay, NY 13331

📞 (315) 357-3629 🌐 Website

Up North Wood Fire Bar & Grill

Bar

4.0 ★★★★☆

• $$ • 📋 Menu

5561 New York 28

Eagle Bay, NY 13331

📞 (315) 390-4444

✨ You've seen all 12 restaurants!

Explore More

Herkimer County County

Explore the whole county

New York Restaurants

Explore the whole state

🗺️ Nearby Cities