Gary Cafe
Cuisine Type
📍 Location & Contact
🕒 Hours & Details
Restaurant Details
📋 Menu
Main
Mash Potatoes & Meatballs
Hamburgers
Dinner Special
Meat Loaf
Soup
Sandwich
Homemade Pie
Appetizers
Hennesy Bbq Wings
Chicken wings glazed in rich Hennessy BBQ sauce. Option for Buffalo Truffle available.
Stuffed Mushrooms
Crab meat.
Fried Green Tomatoes
Calamari
Fresh cut, fried, marinara sauce.
Mussels Appetizer
Shrimp Cocktail
Blue Point Raw Oysters 12
Blue Point Raw Oysters 6
Breakfast
Banana Bread French Toast
Nostalgia 2 By 2
Two eggs with choice of bacon or sausage. Served with 2 pancakes, rye, wheat, or white toast.
Burgers
Beach Burger
Fried egg, american cheese, bacon, served with 1 side of fries.
Desserts
Cheesecake
Fruit Pie
Tiramisu Cake
Carrot Cake
German Chocolate Cake
Pasta
Fettucine Alfredo
Scampi
Sun-dried tomato, basil, white wine, garlic.
Nostalgia Pasta
Poultry
Stuffed Chicken
Ricotta, spinach, lemon butter sauce.
Seafood
Bacon Wrapped Stuffed Shrimp
Jumbo shrimp, crab meat, bacon wrapped, lemon cream sauce.
Baked Rockefeller Oysters 12pc
Baked Rockefeller oysters, 12 pieces. Options include a variety of sides: vegetables, potatoes in seven styles, rice pilaf, salad, or soup.
Baked Rockefeller Oysters 6pc
Baked Rockefeller oysters, choice of enriching sides including asparagus, potatoes in various styles, rice pilaf, sautéed vegetables, greens or simply solo.
Crab Cakes
Fried, housemade sauce.
Fried & Buttered Lake Perch
Lake perch, fried or sautéed, then buttered. Choice of two sides: range from vegetables, potatoes in various styles, rice pilaf, salad, soup, or option to omit second side.
Salmon
Fresh, grilled, lemon butter.
Sauteed & Buttered Lake Perch
Sauteed lake perch with butter. Choice of entrée side includes vegetables, potatoes in various styles, rice pilaf, salad, or soup.
Snow Crab
Hot drawn butter, house seasoned.
Jumbo Shrimp
Jumbo shrimp served with a choice of side: veggies, potatoes in various styles, rice pilaf, salad, soup, or opt for no side.
Lobster Tail
8 oz. tail, hot drawn butter.
Skewered Shrimp
Grilled, lemon butter.
Fried Small Portion Lake Perch
Small portion lake perch, fried. Choose from entrée sides: various potatoes, rice pilaf, salad, soup, or vegetables.
Sauteed Small Portion Lake Perch
Sauteed small portion lake perch. Choice of side: vegetables, potatoes in various preparations, rice pilaf, or salad.
Cat Fish Fillet
Catfish fillet with choice of entrée side: options include various potatoes, rice pilaf, vegetables either sautéed or as salad, and soup.
Coconut Shrimp
Crispy fried, coconut, marmalade.
Soup & Salad
Soup Bowl
Soup Cup
House Salad
Tomato, onion, pepper.
Chicken Caesar Salad
Tomato, crouton, parmesan.
Steaks
Filet Mignon
Tender filet mignon with choice of two sides. Options include various potatoes, asparagus, broccoli, rice pilaf, sautéed vegetables, spinach, salad, soup, or no additional side.
Prime Rib House Special 12oz
12oz prime rib with two side options including vegetables, potatoes in various styles, rice pilaf, salad, or soup.
Lamb Chops
Fresh herb & olive oil marinade, grilled, mustard sauce.
Char Grilled Ribeye 12oz
12oz char-grilled ribeye with two sides. Choose from a variety of vegetables, potatoes in multiple preparations, rice pilaf, salad, soup, or no side.
New York Strip 12 Oz
12 oz New York Strip - Choice of two sides: veggies, potatoes in various styles, salad, soup, or rice pilaf.
Bone In Rib Eye 16oz
16oz bone-in ribeye, choice of two sides from asparagus, variety of potatoes, broccoli, rice pilaf, sautéed vegetables, spinach, sweet potato fries, salad, or soup.
Prime Rib King Cut 22oz
22oz prime rib with two sides. Choose from potato varieties, vegetables like asparagus or spinach, rice pilaf, salad, soup.
Side Orders
Broccoli
Rice Pilaf
Vegetables
Baked Potato
Smashed Potato
Beverages
Diet Pepsi
Pepsi
Sierra Mist
Mtn Dew
Dr Pepper
Premium Sides
Asparagus
Spinach
Sweet Potato Fries
Loaded Potato
Potato topped with crisp bacon bits and melted cheese.
Double Baked Potato
