Black Sheep Bagel Cafe
Cuisine Type
📍 Location & Contact
🕒 Hours & Details
Restaurant Details
📋 Menu
Featured Items
Tofu Veggie Cream Cheese
Per pound.
Tofu Scallion
Per pound.
Create Your Own Sandwich
Create Your Own Sandwich
Choose your base: whole wheat, white, rye breads; multiple wraps; or enjoy on a hero or roll. Select from a variety of meats including ham, turkey, and grilled chicken.
Drinks
Orange Juice
Fresh-squeezed orange juice, available with no pulp or some pulp.
Nesquik
Nesquik beverage, available in chocolate or strawberry flavors.
Snapple
Snapple tea available in Lemon, Peach, Diet variants of Lemon and Peach, and Raspberry.
Vitamin Water
Hydrating vitamin water available in black, yellow, pink, or red flavors.
Yerba Mate
Yerba mate tea available in flavors: enlighten mint, revel berry, bluephoria, orange exuberance, lemon elation.
Gatorade
Sports drink in various flavors: red, blue, purple, frost variations, orange, and yellow. Available in 20 oz.
Pure Leaf
Pure Leaf beverage selection: lemon, peach, sweet tea, unsweetened, raspberry options available.
Hals
Soda in various flavors: Original 20 oz, Vanilla Cream, Lime, Black Cherry.
Celcius
Celcius - A selection of revitalizing beverages available in flavors including citrus, berries, apple, watermelon, and more.
Montauk
Montauk: Your choice of lemonade 20 oz, half-and-half iced tea, green tea, pink lemonade, or raspberry iced tea. Alcoholic.
Essentia 20 Oz Water
A 20 oz bottle of Essentia water, offering a pure and hydrating experience.
Red Bull 8.4oz
An energy drink to keep you energized and focused
Natalies Orange Juice
Natalie's Orange Juice, fresh-squeezed, available in 8 oz, 16 oz, 32 oz sizes.
Hot Coffee
Drip coffee available in 12oz, 16oz, 20oz.
Bottle Drinks
Selection of bottled drinks: Pepsi, Coke, Dr. Pepper, Sprite.
Canned Drinks
Assorted canned sodas including Pepsi, Coke, Sprite, Yoohoo, and Diet Coke.
Iced Coffee
Iced coffee with size options: 16 oz, 24 oz, 32 oz, 44 oz.
Water
Refreshingly chilled water. Available sizes: small, sport, large.
Muffin
Blueberry Crumb Muffin
A muffin featuring a blend of sweet blueberries and a crumbly topping, typically including butter and sugar for a textured finish.
Corn Muffin
Wholesome corn muffin, perfectly sweetened, with a delightfully crumbly texture.
Chocolate Chip Muffin
Decadent muffin baked with rich chocolate chips for a delightful treat.
Double Chocolate Chip Muffin
A double chocolate chip muffin combines rich cocoa batter with chocolate chips for a deeply chocolatey experience.
Triple Chocolate Brownie
A triple chocolate brownie typically includes a blend of milk, dark, and cocoa chocolates, creating a rich texture that's crisp at the edges while moist in the center.
Chips
Sweet Chili Potato Chips
Thinly sliced potato chips seasoned with a sweet and mildly spicy chili flavor, offering a unique twist on the classic snack.
Jalapeño Potato Chips
Kettle-cooked potato chips seasoned with jalapeño for a spicy kick.
Sweet Onion Potato Chips
Thinly sliced potato chips flavored with a hint of sweet onion, typically includes a balance of sweetness and savory notes.
Sour Cream And Onion Potato Chips
Thinly sliced potato chips flavored with a blend of sour cream and onion, offering a tangy and creamy taste profile.
Original Sea Salt Potato Chips
Thinly sliced potatoes, fried and seasoned with sea salt, offering a classic and simple taste.
Honey Bbq Potato Chips
Thinly sliced potato chips coated in a sweet honey barbecue seasoning, offering a unique blend of sweetness and smokiness.
Buffalo Ranch Potato Chips
Potato chips seasoned with a spicy buffalo and tangy ranch flavoring, typically enjoyed as a crispy snack.
Sea Salt And Vinegar Potato Chips
Crispy potato chips seasoned with a harmonious blend of sea salt and tangy vinegar.
Bbq Potato Chips
Thinly sliced potato chips kettle-cooked and seasoned with a smoky barbecue flavor.
Hals Potato Chips
Thinly sliced potatoes, typically deep-fried to a golden crisp, often seasoned with a signature blend of spices unique to Hal's brand.
Acai Bowl
The Original
Acai, homemade gluten free granola, bananas, strawberries, blueberries, coconut flakes.
The Elvis
Acai, homemade gluten free granola, banana, peanut butter, strawberry, chocolate chips.
The Tropical
Acai, homemade gluten free granola, banana, mango, kiwi, pineapple, coconut flakes.
The Date Night
Acai, homemade gluten free granola, nutella, strawberry, sliced almonds.
Specialty Sandwiches
The South Hampton Hero
Roast beef with melted muenster on garlic hero with tomato and peter luger sauce.
The East Hampton
Pastrami, Turkey, coleslaw and Russian on rye.
Hampton Bays
Turkey, ham, Swiss, Russian and coleslaw on rye.
The Quogue
Pastrami, onions, melted Swiss, coleslaw on grilled rye.
The Montauk
Roast beef, Swiss, Russian and coleslaw on rye
The Spicy Roast Beef
Spicy. Grilled roast beef with onions, cheddar, bacon and horseradish mayo.
Pastrami Southwestern
Pastrami, pepper Jack cheese on grilled rye with coleslaw in a wrap.
Chicken Quesadilla
Grilled chicken with melted muenster salsa and chipotle mayo
Greek Chicken Wrap
Grilled chicken with lettuce, tomato, onion and tzatziki sauce in a wrap.
Pastrami Reuben
Pastrami, coleslaw and melted Swiss on rye.
The Southold Wrap
Breaded chicken cutlet in buffalo sauce, blue cheese and lettuce in a wrap.
Pepper Turkey Fajita
Pepper Turkey, sautéed onions, peppers, provolone, chipotle hot sauce in a wrap.
Uncle Phil
Roast beef, peppers, onions, jalapeno cream cheese in a sundried tomato wrap.
The Hot Italian
Hot ham, pepperoni, salami, red onion, lettuce, tomato, melted provolone.
The Jamesport
Grilled chicken, pepper Jack cheese, bacon, tomato, sweet baby rays bbq sauce.
The Aquebogue
Fried chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, bacon, lettuce, tomato, bbq sauce.
Breaded Chicken
Fried cutlet, mozzarella, coleslaw, balsamic.
Egg Salad
Egg salad with smoked salmon, red onion, tomato.
The Mattituck
Honey Turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, avocado, ranch in a wrap.
The Love Lane Wrap
Fried egg plant, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, boars head dressing in a wrap.
The Black Sheeps Sandwich
2 eggs, bacon, sausage, hash brown, syrup on French toast bagel
Cold Cuts by the pound
Turkey
Sliced turkey offered in three sizes: 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb. Ideal for custom sandwiches.
Ham
Pork ham available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb sizes.
Honey Turkey
Honey turkey, available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb options.
Roast Beef
Roast beef, available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb options.
Smoked Pastrami
Smoked pastrami available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb portions.
Genoa Salami
Genoa salami available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb portions.
Pepperoni
Pepperoni slices available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb options.
Bologna
Bologna, available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb sizes.
Salads
Egg Salad By The Pound
Egg salad available in servings of 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb.
Chicken Salad By The Pound
Chicken salad available in servings of 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb options.
Whitefish Salad By The Pound
Whitefish salad, available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb servings.
Tuna Salad By The Pound
Tuna salad available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb servings.
Macaroni Salad By The Pound
Macaroni salad available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb servings.
Potato Salad By The Pound
Potato salad available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb servings.
Coleslaw By The Pound
Coleslaw, choice of 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb servings.
Egg Salad Sandwich
Egg salad sandwich with choice of bagels, including plain, various seed toppings, whole wheat, and specialty flavors, or wraps like spinach and sundried tomato.
Chicken Salad Sandwich
Chicken salad with choice of bagels including plain, whole wheat, assorted flavors (sesame, onion, etc.), or wraps (whole wheat, spinach, sundried tomato). Served on bread, hero or roll also available.
Whitefish Salad Sandwich
Whitefish salad on a selection of bagels or wraps, including flavors like asiago cheese, jalapeño cheddar, and whole wheat, among other options.
Tuna Salad Sandwich
Tuna salad sandwich with choice of bagels, including plain, various seeds, whole wheat, or specialty flavors, wraps, and breads like rye and hero.
Parfaits
Classic Parfait
Vanilla yogurt, gluten free granola, strawberries, blueberries.
Omelette
The Leo
Lox and red onions.
The Western
Ham, cheese, peppers and onions.
South Beach
Tomatoes, onions, olives and peppers.
Farm Fresh
Turkey bacon, spinach, avocado and salsa.
Loco Pollo
Grilled chicken, avocado, salsa and pepperJack cheese.
Cheese Omelette
3 eggs, cheese.
The Italian Omelette
Ham, pepperoni, salami, provolone, red onion, tomato.
Steak And Eggs
London broil roast beef, peppers, onions, provolone.
The Nofo Omelette
Roasted red peppers, sautéed spinach, fresh mozzarella, egg whites.
The Main Road Omelette
Sautéed spinach, onions, broccoli, goat cheese.
The Peconic Omelette
Jalapeños, avocado, diced tomato, pepper Jack, mozzarella, chipotle hot sauce.
Breakfast Sandwiches
They Spicy Hobo
Spicy. Two eggs, bacon, pepper Jack cheese, hash brown and hot sauce.
Hobo
Two eggs, bacon, cheese and hash brown.
The Powerhouse
Two egg whites, Turkey, lettuce, tomato and hot sauce in a wrap.
The Hungry Man
Three eggs, bacon, ham, sausage, cheese and hash brown on a hero.
The Hungry Woman
Egg whites, Turkey bacon, spinach, Swiss.
Bacon Egg And Cheese
Bacon, egg, and cheese on your choice of bagels ranging from plain to flavored, various wraps, whole wheat, white, or rye bread, or a hero. Wide selection of bagels includes sesame, cinnamon, everything, and specialty options.
Ham Egg And Cheese
Choice of ham, egg, and cheese breakfast sandwich on various bagels or wraps, including plain, whole wheat, jalapeño cheddar, spinach, and sundried tomato options.
Sausage Egg And Cheese
Sausage, egg, and cheese on your choice of bagels including varieties like Asiago, jalapeño cheddar, or wraps. Options range from whole wheat to sundried tomato.
Egg Whites With Bacon, Ham Or Sausage, Cheese
Egg whites combined with your choice of bacon, sausage, or ham, layered with cheese. Pick from an extensive selection of bread and wraps, ranging from various bagel types to different wraps and bread.
Egg And Cheese
Egg and cheese, select from a diverse range of bagels or wraps, including whole wheat, sesame, jalapeño cheddar, and more; also available on a hero or roll.
Egg Whites And Cheese
Egg whites and cheese on a choice of bagels or wraps, including varieties like whole wheat, spinach, asiago, jalapeño cheddar, and more.
Two Egg Whites
Two egg whites in your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread including options like whole wheat, sundried tomato wrap, or asiago cheese bagel.
Two Eggs
Two eggs nestled between your choice of various bagels, from classic plain to jalapeño cheddar bacon, or opt for wraps and more. Select to personalize your breakfast sandwich.
B.l.t (bacon, Lettuce, Tomato)
Crisp bacon, fresh lettuce, and tomato on choice of bagels ranging from plain to jalapeño cheddar bacon, or various wraps including spinach and sundried tomato.
North Fork Special
Smoked salmon, cream cheese, red onion, capers, tomato on a bagel.
The Black Sheeps Sandwich
2 eggs, bacon, sausage, hash browns and syrup on a French Toast bagel
Cream Cheese & Butter
Butter On A Bagel
Butter spread over choice of bagels: plain to exotic like Asiago cheese, whole wheat varieties, classics like cinnamon raisin, to unique flavors like jalapeño cheddar bacon.
Plain Cream Cheese On A Bagel
Plain cream cheese spread on a choice of bagels including classic, whole wheat, everything varieties, and distinct options like asiago, jalapeño cheddar. Select from over 30 flavors.
Vegetable Cream Cheese On A Bagel
Vegetable cream cheese spread on choice of bagel including plain, whole wheat varieties, assorted toppings (sesame, poppy, onion), and specialized options like asiago, jalapeño cheddar.
Scallion Cream Cheese On A Bagel
Scallion cream cheese spread over your choice of bagel: plain to exotic like asiago cheese, diverse "flats" options, whole wheat varieties, and flavors ranging from sweet to savory.
Cucumber Dill Cream Cheese On A Bagel
Cucumber dill cream cheese spread on choice of bagel, including plain, savory, sweet, whole wheat, flats, or cheese-enhanced varieties.
Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese On A Bagel
Walnut raisin cream cheese spread on your choice of bagel, including variations like asiago cheese, jalapeño cheddar, and pretzel options.
Honey Cranberry Cream Cheese On A Bagel
Honey cranberry cream cheese spread over a choice of bagels including plain, seeded, whole wheat, flavored, asiago, or pretzel variations.
Olive Cream Cheese On A Bagel
Rich olive cream cheese spread over a freshly baked bagel. Choice of bagel includes plain, whole wheat varieties, flavored, cheese, and more.
Jalepeño Cream Cheese On A Bagel
Jalapeño cream cheese spread on bagel. Choice of plain to specialty bagels including whole wheat, pumpernickel, asiago, and more. Opt for flats for a thinner version.
Lox Cream Cheese On A Bagel
Lox cream cheese spread on a choice of bagels, including plain, whole grain, flavored, or flat varieties. Options for cheese and spiced bagels available.
Strawberry Cream Cheese On A Bagel
Strawberry cream cheese spread on choice of bagel including traditional, whole wheat, flavored, asiago cheese, jalapeño cheddar, pretzel, and more varieties.
Tofu Cream Cheese On A Bagel
Tofu cream cheese spread on choice of bagel. Options include plain, assorted seeds, whole wheat variants, flavored, and specialty bagels like asiago cheese and jalapeño cheddar.
Tofu Vegetable Cream Cheese On A Bagel
Tofu and vegetable cream cheese spread on your choice bagel; selections include plain, whole wheat, and specialty options such as asiago cheese, jalapeño cheddar bacon, and pretzel.
Butter By The Pound
Butter by the Pound - Choice of cream cheese serving: 1/4lb, 1/2lb, or 1lb.
Plain Cream Cheese By The Pound
Plain cream cheese available in servings of 1/4lb, 1/2lb, or 1lb.
Vegetable Cream Cheese By The Pound
Vegetable cream cheese available in 1/4lb, 1/2lb, 1lb servings.
Scallion Cream Cheese By The Pound
Scallion cream cheese available in 1/4lb, 1/2lb, and 1lb servings.
Cucumber Dill Cream Cheese By The Pound
Cucumber dill cream cheese, options for 1/4lb, 1/2lb, or 1lb servings.
Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese By The Pound
Walnut and raisin cream cheese available in three sizes: 1/4lb, 1/2lb, or 1lb.
Honey Cranberry Cream Cheese By The Pound
Honey cranberry cream cheese available in 1/4lb, 1/2lb, or 1lb servings.
Olive Cream Cheese By The Pound
Olive cream cheese available in 1/4lb, 1/2lb, and 1lb servings.
Jalepeño Cream Cheese By The Pound
Jalapeño cream cheese available in 1/4lb, 1/2lb, and 1lb servings.
Lox Cream Cheese By The Pound
Lox cream cheese available in 1/4lb, 1/2lb, or 1lb servings.
Strawberry Cream Cheese By The Pound
Strawberry cream cheese available in 1/4lb, 1/2lb, or 1lb servings.
Tofu Cream Cheese By The Pound
Tofu cream cheese, available in 1/4lb, 1/2lb, and 1lb servings.
Tofu Vegetable Cream Cheese By The Pound
Tofu vegetable cream cheese available in 1/4lb, 1/2lb, 1lb servings.
Tofu Scallion Cream Cheese On A Bagel
Tofu scallion cream cheese spread on choice of bagel, including plain, sesame, whole wheat varieties, everything variations, flats options, and unique flavors like jalapeño cheddar bacon.
Tofu Scallion Cream Cheese By Pound
Tofu scallion cream cheese available in 1/4lb, 1/2lb, and 1lb servings.
Smoked Salmon
Thin Sliced Acme Smoked Salmon *note temperature sensitive item*
Paninis
The Dave Matthews Panini
Sautéed spinach, tomato, fresh mozzarella and pesto on a rosemary garlic ciabatta topped with balsamic glaze.
The Foo Fighters Panini
Grilled chicken, sautéed spinach, roasted red peppers fresh mozzarella, balsamic dressing.
The Beatles Panini
Fried eggplant, sautéed spinach, roasted red peppers fresh mozzarella, balsamic glaze.
The Ac/dc Panini
Breaded chicken, bacon, cheddar, ranch on home baked white bread.
The Slash Panini
Ham, Swiss, mustard on rye.
The Billy Joel Panini
Grilled chicken, avocado, tomato, tzatziki sauce on whole grain bread.
The David Grohl Panini
Roast beef, melted muenster, onions horseradish sauce on a hero.
The Elton John Panini
Turkey, coleslaw, Russian on whole grain bread.
The Slightly Stoopid Panini
Breaded chicken cutlet, chipotle gouda chipotle mayo, bacon tomato.
The Coheed Cubano
Ham, Swiss, pickles, onions, mustard.
Whole Wheat Flats
Whole Wheat Flats (each)
Whole wheat flatbread available in flavors: plain, sesame, poppy, everything, onion, sunflower, whole wheat everything.
Whole Wheat Flats (dozen)
Whole wheat flats, dozen, with choice of assorted flavors: plain, sesame, poppy, everything blend, onion, sunflower, or whole wheat everything. Mix and match permitted.
Flats
Flats (each)
Flats offered in various flavors: plain, sesame, poppy, everything mix, onion, sunflower seed, or egg with everything seasoning.
Flats (dozen)
Customize your dozen with a selection from plain, sesame, poppy, everything, onion, sunflower, and egg everything flavors. Mix and match permitted.
Bagels
Plain
Each.
Poppy
Each.
Sesame
Each.
Onion
Each.
Everything
Each.
Cinnamon Raisin
Each.
Whole Wheat
Each.
Egg Bagel
Each.
Garlic
Each.
Salt
Each.
Pumpernickel
Each.
Egg Everything
Each.
Whole Wheat Everything
Each.
Whole Wheat Sesame
Each.
Pumpernickel Everything
Each.
Bagel Dozen
Choose 12 from a variety of bagels including plain, savory options like onion, garlic, salt, various seed toppings, sweet choices like cinnamon raisin, and whole wheat variations.
French Toast Bagel
A bagel infused with the flavors of French toast, typically including a hint of cinnamon and a subtle sweetness reminiscent of the classic breakfast dish.
Cinnamon French Toast Bagel
A sweetly spiced bagel infused with the flavors of cinnamon and french toast, typically includes a hint of vanilla.
Asiago Cheese
A freshly baked bagel encrusted with asiago cheese, offering a unique blend of textures and a rich, cheesy flavor.
Jalapeno Cheddar
A bagel infused with jalapeño pieces and cheddar cheese, offering a balance of spicy and savory flavors.
Jalapeno Cheddar Bacon
A bagel infused with jalapeño and cheddar, topped with crispy bacon.
Pretzel Bagel
A pretzel bagel combines the distinct, chewy texture of a traditional bagel with the salty, glossy crust of a pretzel, typically served plain.
Mozzarella Garlic Herb
A toasted bagel generously topped with melted mozzarella, infused with a blend of garlic and herbs.
French Toast Bagel
A bagel infused with the flavors of French toast, typically including a sweet cinnamon blend.
Cinnamon French Toast Bagel
A bagel infused with cinnamon and French toast flavors, typically includes a sweet cinnamon blend.
Asiago Cheese
A freshly baked bagel encrusted with asiago cheese, typically includes a creamy interior.
Jalapeno Cheddar
A bagel infused with spicy jalapeños and melted cheddar cheese, typically includes a blend of enriched flour, water, salt, and yeast.
Jalapeno Cheddar Bacon
A bagel generously topped with jalapeño slices, melted cheddar cheese, and crispy bacon.
Pretzel Bagel
A pretzel bagel combines the traditional, dense texture of a bagel with the distinct, salty crust of a pretzel, typically served as a unique twist on classic bagel varieties.
Mozzarella Garlic Herb Bagel
A freshly baked bagel infused with garlic and herbs, topped with melted mozzarella cheese.
