Theodore's at Madison Bay

Dry Rubbed

Choice of 6 or 10 wings. Choice of one FREE sauce: BBQ, ranch, bleu cheese, maple sriracha, garlic parmesan, spicy arbol

Garlic Parmesan Wings

Choice of 6 or 10 wings. Choice of one sauce: BBQ, ranch, bleu cheese, maple sriracha, garlic parmesan, spicy arbol

Spicy Arbol

Choice of 6 or 10 wings. Choice of one sauce: BBQ, ranch, bleu cheese, maple sriracha, garlic parmesan, spicy arbol

Buffalo Style

Choice of 6 or 10 wings. Choice of one sauce: BBQ, ranch, bleu cheese, maple sriracha, garlic parmesan, or spicy arbol.

Bowl Of Chili

Ground beef chili with onion, peppers, and beans

Steak & Chimichurri

10 oz Flank | Chimichurri | Fries | Broccolini | Cherry Tomato

Fried Chicken Sandwich

Fried Chicken breast, dill pickles, togarashi spicy aioli on a brioche bun. Choice of fries, tots, or mixed greens.

Fettuccine Rosa

Fettuccine, creamy tomato, broccoli, cherry tomato, spinach. Vegetarian. Add Grilled Chicken $6 or Salmon $9.

Burrito Bowl

Your choice of protein, Mexican rice (has chicken broth), pico de gallo, pickled red onion, pinto beans, & avocado. Your choice of mild salsa verde or spicy arbol Choose from: Tinga, Carnitas, Al Pastor, Chorizo, Steak, Vegan Cauliflower & sweet potato (no rice included and the beans are made vegan).

Beer Battered Fish Tacos

Beer battered cod, togarashi spicy aioli, pico de gallo on corn tortillas served with Mexican rice & beans

Fish Fry **friday Only**

This Wisconsin favorite is served Wednesdays and Fridays. Two pieces of beer battered cod, coleslaw, tartar, and lemon. Your choice of tots or fries.

Sliders

Your choice of two sliders and choice of fries, tots, or spring mix

Authentic Tacos

Mix and match your choice of tacos. Select mild verde or spicy arbol

Shrimp Pasta Al Limone

Grilled Jumbo Shrimp | Lemon Cream | Parsley | Fettuccine

Seared Ahi Tuna Sandwich

Seared Ahi Tuna Steak | Dynamite Sauce | Apple & Radish Slaw | Ponzu | Brioche Bun

Greek Grilled Chicken Mediterranean Plate

Grilled Chicken, tomato cucumber salad, hummus, pita, lemon rice

Blackened Salmon

8oz Salmon fillet*, with a honey mustard glaze, scallion mashed potatoes, sauteed broccoli

Vegan Tacos

Roasted Cauliflower, Sweet Potato, black bean taco with a chipotle cashew cream, & avocado

Coconut Shrimp

Jumbo coconut shrimp paired with our homemade smoky chipotle mayo. Choose 6 or 10 Shrimp

Warm Pretzel Bites

Toasty pretzel bites, perfectly seasoned and served with jalapeno nacho cheese. Add our tangy honey mustard for $1. Vegetarian.

Cheese Curds

Beer battered curds with homemade ranch. Vegetarian

Big Nachos

Choice of Chicken Tinga, Steak, Pork Carnitas, or Chorizo. Topped with pinto beans, jalapeño queso, salsa roja, crema, & pico de gallo.

Spin Dip

Spinach & artichoke dip, warm pita, celery & carrots. Vegetarian.

Shrimp Ceviche

Mexican style shrimp ceviche marinated in lime juice. Finely dice jalapeno, tomato, red onion, and cilantro. Topped with avocado and a side of spicy arbol. Paired with house fried chips

Local Charcuterie

Local Cheese (2) | One Meat | Wine Marinated Raisins | Cornichons | Fruit | Jam | Potter's Crackers

Bowl Of Chili

Ground beef chili, onions, bell peppers, and beans

Lemon Chicken & Rice Soup

Brothy chicken and rice soup with celery, carrots, and onions. Dairy Free!

Pozole Rojo (cup)

Tomato Basil

Pozole Rojo (meal)

Red pork pozole with hominy, cabbage, onion, cilantro, lime

Potato Ham Soup

Creamy potato and ham topped with sour cream, bacon, and sour cream

Caprese Flatbread

Basil pesto, tomato, mozzarella, red pepper flakes & balsamic glaze. Vegetarian.

Cauliflower Bites

Crispy cauliflower bites tossed in our maple sriracha with chipotle aioli OR choose our buffalo with bleu cheese crumbles and scallions. Vegetarian.

The Madison Burger

Two 4oz Fox Heritage Farms beef patties*, American cheese, dijonnaise, pickles, brioche bun. Choice of fries, tots, or mixed greens.

Black Bean Burger

Chipotle black bean burger, dijonnaise, dill pickles, topped with pico de gallo. Choice of fries, tots, or mixed greens.

Steak And Bleu Salad

Flank Steak | Bleu Cheese Dressing | Bleu Cheese Crumbles | Grilled Red Onion | Grilled Corn | Cherry Tomato | Romaine

Cobb Salad

Avocado | Grape Tomatoes | Red Onion | Bacon | Hard Boiled Egg | Spring mix | Corn | Bleu Cheese Dressing | Croutons

Caesar Salad

Romaine | House-made Caesar | Parmesan Cheese | Croutons | Red onion

Strawberry & Feta Salad

Raspberry Vinaigrette | Strawberries | Pecans | Feta | Romaine | Spinach | Red Onion

Fries

Tater Tots

Served with a side of ketchup

Cheese Fries

Homemade Jalapeño queso and fries

Extra Dipping Sauces

Selection of 18 dipping sauces. Choices include ranch, bleu cheese, maple sriracha, BBQ, and buffalo. Other options: Caesar, ketchup, mayo, mustard, nacho cheese, balsamic dressing, garlic parmesan, togarashi aioli, avocado, mango habanero, sour cream, spicy arbol, lemon pepper vinaigrette.

Sauteed Broccolini

Sauteed broccolini in oil, salt, and pepper.

Mashed Potatoes

Creamy scallion mashed potatoes

Plasticware

Add this item to your cart and the restaurant will include silverware with your order.

Key Lime Pie

Milk Shake

Our sister ice cream shop, Good News Ice Cream can whip you up a delicious milk shake! Call us at 608-229-0900 if you would like to ask about our Non- Dairy options that we may have available for a non-dairy shake. We offer Oat Milk for shakes.

Ginger Beer

Red Bull

Sugar free or regular.

Jarritos

Assorted Jarritos sodas: choose from refreshing options including Mandarin, Lime, Guava, Fruit Punch, Pineapple, Tamarind, and Mango.

Mexican Coke

Sprecher Cream Soda

Sprecher Root Beer