New Berlin Fish House and Oyster Bar

Pick 2

Choose two from a variety of fresh seafood: shrimp, clam strips, scallops, oysters, snapper, mahi-mahi, salmon, trigger fish, grouper, flounder. Options for preparation: fried, broiled, blackened, with gluten-free variations available.

Grouper

Grouper with two side choices: various veggies, potatoes, corn, and fries available, gluten-free options included. Preparation options: fried, broiled, or blackened, with gluten-free variations for certain methods.

Local Shrimp

Shellfish.

Pick 3

Customize with any 3 seafood choices: shrimp, clam strips, scallops, oysters, snapper, mahi-mahi, salmon, trigger fish, grouper, flounder. Preparation: fried, broiled, blackened (options include gluten-free).

Local Mayport Flounder

Local Mayport flounder with choice of preparation: fried, broiled, or blackened. Options include gluten-free. Select two sides from bacon collard greens, pimento cheese grits, coleslaw, mashed potatoes, corn, fries, or green beans.

Red Snapper

Red snapper with two sides. Options include various sides, gluten-free available. Preparation: fried, broiled, or blackened, with or without gluten.

Atlantic Mahi-mahi

Atlantic Mahi-Mahi served with two sides. Side options include collard greens, cheese grits, coleslaw, mashed potatoes, corn, fries, and green beans, available in gluten-free. Preparation: fried, broiled, or blackened.

Gulf Oysters

Small to medium in size very briny.

Virginia Clam Strips

Freshly shucked.

Honey Glazed Salmon

Honey glazed salmon served with two side options: various greens, grits, slaws, potatoes, corn, fries in regular or gluten-free. Preparation: fried, broiled, blackened— also with gluten-free choices.

Cold Water Scallops

Sushi grade

Chef Jason's Brussels

Gluten-Free Available. Crispy Brussels sprouts, balsamic reduction, azar sausage, bacon, caramelized onions and goat cheese crumbles.

Mama Shaw's Conch Fritters

Legendary Bahamian mama Shaw's very own recipe.

Gator Tail

Tender chunks of Florida gator tail, fried or blackened.

Grouper Nuggets

Gulf grouper, fried or blackened, served with our house-made tartar sauce.

Bang Bang Shrimp

Gulf shrimp tossed in our house-made buffalo sauce.

Crispy Calamari

Fresh calamari and banana peppers cooked light and crispy, served with a side of chilled marinara.

Coconut Crusted Shrimp

Crispy hand battered shrimp rolled in fresh coconut.

Smoked Fish Dip

Smoked fresh catch served with captains wafers.

Fried Green Tomatoes

Crispy fried green tomatoes served over a pimento cheese spread, topped with a corn Pico, balsamic reduction, and goat cheese.

House-made Hushpuppies & Jam

Sweet onion dough fried golden brown, served with house-made jam.

Ahi Tuna*

Seared ahi tuna, seaweed salad, corn Pico, pickled onions, cucumber wasabi sauce.

Deviled Bacon Oysters

5 Homemade deviled eggs topped with crispy gulf fried oyster, buffalo bacon & blue cheese crumble.

3/4 Cheddar Angus Beef Burger

Fresh private label ground beef with cheddar cheese, marinated tomatoes, pickled onion and spring mix.

Russ' Tacos

Choice of shrimp or grouper in two flour tortillas with spring mix, marinated tomatoes, corn Pico, shredded cheese, pickled onions and house-made taco sauce.

Hot Lobster Roll

Fresh whole Maine lobster cooked & cracked in house, served hot & drenched in real butter

Po'boy

Shrimp or oysters in a locally-baked roll topped with spring mix, shredded cheese, marinated tomatoes, pickled onion and house-made po'boy sauce.

Captain's Platter Combination

Fresh local shrimp, cold water scallops, fresh fish, fried select oysters and house-made stuffed deviled crab.

Just Caught Stuffed Grouper

Gulf grouper loaded with house-made crab meat stuffing and cheese.

Lobster Ricotta Cheese Ravioli

Chunks of Maine lobster meat, cherry tomatoes, caramelized onions, tossed in a parmesan white wine sauce.

Low Country Boil

Gluten-Free available. Local jumbo shrimp, azar sausage, potatoes, corn and onion.

Margo's Crab Cakes

Creamy Maryland style with hints of tangy mustard and zesty lemon, topped with corn Pico.

Chicken Tenders Meal

White meat chicken strips, blackened or fried.

Poke Bowl*

Fresh ahi tuna, seasonal veggies, mildly hot poke sauce & sticky rice.

Alaskan Crab Legs

2 lbs of snow crab served with choice of 2 sides.

Whole Maine Lobster Dinner

Available Gluten Free. 1.25 lb lobster served with 2 sides.

Shrimp And Cheese Tortellini

Pan seared local shrimp, tri-colored cheese tortellini tossed in a white wine herb sauce & topped with goat cheese.

Sweet Potato Fries

Pimento Cheese Grits

Available Gluten Free.

Rustic Mashed Potatoes

Available Gluten Free.

French Fries

Coleslaw

Available Gluten Free.

Corn On The Cobb

Available Gluten Free.

Bacon Collards Greens

Available Gluten Free.

Green Beans

Available Gluten Free.

Somthin' N' Grits

Available Gluten Free. Your choice of shrimp, lobster or fresh-caught grouper with smoked bacon, local Azar sausage, peppers & onion served over creamy pimento cheese grits.

Caesar Salad

Romaine, croutons, cherry tomatoes and parmesan.

Capt. Frank's Fish Chowder

Creamy and loaded with fresh fish.

Lump Crab Meat Stew

Aunt Liz's secret recipe with heaps of blue crab meat.

Walnut & Beet Salad

Spring mix, candied walnuts, roasted beets, goat cheese, marinated tomatoes, topped with balsamic reduction & a local honey drizzle.

House Salad

Spring mix, tomatoes, pickled onions, shredded cheese and croutons.

Fish House Sangria

House red, blackberry brandy, pomegranate and cranberry juice topped with fresh seasonal berries.

Loaded Fish House Bloody Mary

Tito's vodka, zing zang bloody Mary mix, seasonal veggies, crab leg, local shrimp and topped with a raw oyster in shell.

Blackberry Splash

Vodka, fresh blackberries, lemon honey simple, mint, pimms, cucumber topped with ginger beer and a lime wheel.

Painkiller

Cream de coconut, orange & pineapple juice topped with dark rum & fresh nutmeg

Champagne Cocktail

Choice of orange, cranberry or pomegranate.

Long Island Ice Tea

Vodka, silver rum, gin, triple sec topped with homemade sour, garnished with a lemon wheel.

Goombay Smash

Coconut rum, dark rum, apricot brandy, orange and pineapple juice, garnished with an orange wheel.

Peel N Eat Jumbo Local Shrimp

1/2 Lb.

Peel N Eat Royal Deepwater Shrimp

1/2 Lb.

Fish House Style Charbroiled

6 gulf oysters topped with butter, garlic, red pepper, parmesan and Romano.

Jalapeño Bacon Cheddar

6 gulf oysters topped with bacon, cheddar and jalapeño.

Key Lime Pie

We discovered this recipe on our annual lobster trip. It's famous!

Sawgrass Chocolate Cake

4 layers of double chocolate heaven

Mermaid's Tale

Tito's vodka, Giffard violet, lavender vanilla simple, splash of home-made lemonade

Florarita

Silver tequila, ruby red grapefruit, thyme simple, gran gala & topped with house-made sour & an orange wheel

The Ponce

St. Augustine gin, fresh blueberries, thyme, elderflower, & house-made sour

Camelot

Chardonnay, California

Edna Valley

Pinot grigio, California

Pine Ridge

Chenin blanc, California

Whitehaven

Sauvignon blanc, New Zealand

Nautilus

Sauvignon blanc, Marlborough

Sonoma Cutrer

Chardonnay, California

Camelot

Pinot grigio, California

Figuiere

Rose, France

La Marca Prosecco

Split, Italy

Wycliff

Champagne

Camelot

Cabernet, California

Catena

Malbec, Argentina

Camelot

Pinot noir, California

Firesteed

Pinot noir, Williamette Valley

Lyric

Pinot noir, California

J. Lohr

Cabernet, California

Renegade

Cabernet, Paso Robles, California

Corona Light

Mexico 4.1%.

Stella Artois

Belgium, 5.2%

Budweiser

Missouri 5%.

Bud Light

Missouri 4.2%.

Coors Light

Colorado 4.2%.

Michelob Ultra

Missouri 4.2%.

Angry Orchard

Missouri 5%.

Miller Lite

Wisconsin, 4.17%

Corona

Mexico 4.1%.

Pabst Blue Ribbon

Wisconsin 4.7%.

Funky Buddah Floridian

Oakland Park, Florida 5.2%.

Whiteclaw, Hard Seltzer

Glendale, Arizona 5%

Founders All Day Ipa

Michigan 4.7%.

Intuition Jon Boat English Golden Ale

Florida 4.5%

Bud Light

Missouri, 4.2%.

Michelob Ultra

Missouri, 4.2%.

Yuengling

Pennsylvania 4.5%.

Duke's Brown Ale

Florida 6%.

Blue Moon

Missouri, 4.2%

Intuition I-10 Ipa

Florida 5.5%.