Billy's Tarpon Turtle

Authentic English Fish & Chips

Crispy beer battered domestic cod, served with tackle fries and coleslaw.

E. Sea Rider Mahi

Grilled skewers of shrimp and sea scallops paired with a fillet of mahi. Served over yellow rice.

E. Sea Rider Salmon

Grilled skewers of shrimp and sea scallops paired with a fillet of salmon. Served over yellow rice.

Rusty's Signature Salmon

Rich + delicious Faroe Island Salmon, atop fingerling potatoes and fresh veggies. Finished with a light lemon dill sauce.

Madame Butterfly

Fresh gulf shrimp, grilled, blackened or fried. Served with two sides.

Jack's Shrimp Trio

Straight off the Julie Ann! 6 peel + eat shrimp, bellie banger shrimp, and shrimp scampi.

Fat Cat Chicken Cajun Alfredo

Cajun alfredo topped with blackened chicken. Served over linguini.

Little Joe

A trio of bay scallops, gulf shrimp and mussels in a delicious alfredo sauce over linguini.

Seafood Mac & Cheese

Creamy sharp cheddar and gruyere sauce over rigatoni with layers of gulf shrimp and bay scallops. Served with garlicky toast points.

86 Proof

Faroe island salmon and bacon-wrapped scallops, over jasmine rice and veggies. Finished with a sweet bourbon glaze.

Hard Times Po' Boy

Fried shrimp, lettuce, tomato, dill sauce, and scallions. Served with kettle chips.

90 Miles To Cuban

Slow roasted mojo pork, salami, Swiss cheese, pickles, and MM sauce on Cuban bread, and pressed to perfection.

Double Eagle Chicken Sandwich

A boneless breast of chicken, served grilled or blackened, with melted cheddar and bacon.

Anclote Cluck

The ultimate fried chicken sandwich! Bacon, sweet and spicy buffalo honey, pickled red onions, blue cheese, and bibb lettuce.

Market Mahi Sandwich

Fried mahi, Bibb lettuce, pickled red onion, avocado, tomato, and cilantro lime sauce on a toasted bun.

Big Beautiful Burger

Housemade burger topped with melted cheese, bacon and the works.

The Big Ka-tuna Rice Bowl

Jasmine rice topped with raw, marinated ahi tuna, fresh veggies, pineapple, seaweed salad, avocado, sesame. Seeds, masago and finished with spicy mayo.

Greek Salad

Kalamata olives, cukes, bell peppers, onion, wedge tomato, chickpeas, beets, and feta cheese. Topped with a scoop of potato salad.

Kitchen Sink & Greens

A bowl of beautiful mixed greens, homemade puffed rice, grilled halloumi cheese, sliced cucumbers, heirloom tomatoes, red onion, watermelon radish, avocado, chipotle aioli and topped with crispy panko chicken. Served with warm naan bread.

Little Poke

Fire. Raw, ahi tuna diced and lightly marinated in a sesame soy dressing. Served atop veggies and finished with masago, avocado, and poke mayo.

Rusty's Cobb Salad

Fried gulf shrimp, bacon, egg, tomato, onion, cheddar cheese, and a pinch of fried onion straws.

Bellie's Signature Salad

Mixed greens, candied pecans, golden raisins, green apple, red onion, tomato, and goat cheese crumbles. Served with honey lemon poppy seed dressing.

Caesar Salad

Romaine, homemade croutons, parmesan cheese, and homemade dressing.

Blackened Salmon Spinach Salad

Spinach, chopped egg, bacon, onion, tomato, sunflower seeds, dried cranberries, key lime vinaigrette, and topped with blackened salmon.

1946 Steak Salad

Mixed greens Caesar with creamy homemade dressing, grape tomatoes and shaved parmesan. Topped with sliced sirloin and crispy scotch egg.

Calamari

A mound of tender calamari, fried to perfection. Served with marinara.

Bellie Banger Grouper

Fried and tossed in a mildly spicy honey mustard sauce.

Garlic Peel & Eat Shrimp

A big bowl of shrimp in our signature garlic white wine. Served with bread for dipping.

Chicken Wings

10 wings, fried and tossed in mildly spicy sweet buffalo sauce.

Garlic Mussels

A big bowl of black mussels in our signature garlic white wine. Served with bread for dipping.

Feta Artichoke Dip

Served warm with corn tortilla chips.

Bellie Banger Shrimp

Fried and tossed in a mildly spicy honey mustard sauce.

Buffalo Shrimp

Fried shrimp tossed in buffalo wing sauce. Served with blue cheese and celery.

Edamame

Choice of: juicy sauce style, chili + lime, salted.

Ceviche Stack

Layers of homemade guacamole, fresh ceviche + mango salsa. Served with chips.

Garlic Middleneck Clams

A big bowl of middleneck clams in our signature garlic white wine. Served with bread for dipping.

Ceviche

Fresh fish, shrimp and scallops, marinated with tomato, onion, herbs and spices. Served with crispy tortilla chips.

Teeha Marie Fish Spread

Smoked fresh, in-house. Served with assorted crackers.

Brussels Sprouts

Crispy sprouts tossed in a garlicky parm dressing. Topped with grated parmesan and lemon.

Snow Crab Clusters

Weighed to order, a full pound and a half of the best snow crab you'll find!

1/2 Lb Peel & Eat Shrimp

Traditional jack juice, a signature blend of olive oil, lemon + spices. Caught on our own boat! Served hot, peel + eat style.

1 Lb Peel & Eat Shrimp

Traditional jack juice, a signature blend of olive oil, lemon + spices. Caught on our own boat! Served hot, peel + eat style.

Rusty's Pot Belly Bucket

Traditional jack juice, a signature blend of olive oil, lemon + spices. Snow crab, gulf shrimp, mussels, clams, smoked sausage, corn, potatoes, citrus + a hard-boiled egg for good luck!

1/2 Dz. Cedar Key Middleneck Clams

Half dozen Cedar Key middleneck clams, choice of traditional jack juice with olive oil, lemon, spices, or plain steamed.

1 Dz. Cedar Key Middleneck Clams

Cedar Key middleneck clams, either in traditional Jack juice with olive oil, lemon, and spices, or plain steamed.

Shrimp Bisque

Seafood Gumbo

Chicken Dakota

A perfectly pan-seared breast of chicken with sautéed artichokes and fire-roasted tomatoes in a light lemon cream sauce. Served over rice and finished with feta cheese and basil.

16 Oz Blackboard Steak

The best big ribeye in town! Seasoned and grilled perfectly. Served with two sides and fresh bread.

Grouper Tacos

Two flour tortillas filled with grouper, shredded cabbage, pico de gallo, cheddar cheese and chipotle ranch. Served with black beans and rice.

Fresh Catch Tacos

Two flour tortillas filled with shredded cabbage, pico de gallo, cheddar cheese, and chipotle ranch. Served with black beans and rice.

Shrimp Tacos

Two flour tortillas filled with shrimp, shredded cabbage, pico de gallo, cheddar cheese and chipotle ranch. Served with black beans and rice.

Chicken Tacos

Two flour tortillas filled with chicken, shredded cabbage, pico De gallo, cheddar cheese, and chipotle ranch. Served with black beans and rice.

Tackle Fries

Corn Casserole

Yellow Rice

Artisan Bread Basket

Green Beans & Shiitake Mushrooms

Black Beans & Rice

Potato Salad

Loaded Skillet Fries

Brussels Sprout Gratin With Bacon

Coleslaw

Coconut Cake

Southern Chocolate Cake

Key Lime Pie

Kid's Chicken

Fried chicken with options: grilled or fried. Comes with applesauce or tackle fries. Kid-friendly portion.

Kid's Kraft Mac & Cheese

Served with french fries or apple sauce.

Kid's Fried Fish

Fried mahi mahi.

Kid's Pasta

Kid's pasta with choice of alfredo, drawn butter, marinara, or plain sauce.

Kid's Shrimp

Old Fashioned Coke Bottle

Saratoga Water (still)

Old Fashioned Sprite Bottle

Saratoga Water (sparkling)