Carol Of Caseys Pizza Shop

X-large - 12 Cut

Indulge in a 16 inch, 12-cut pizza, topped with your choice of red or white sauce, from our traditional Italian menu.

Large - 10 Cut

Freshly baked large pizza with choice of red or white sauce, covered in our 100% cheese blend.

Medium - 8 Cut

Medium 8-cut traditional Italian pizza with your choice of white or red sauce.

Small - 4 Cut

Freshly baked, four-cut pizza with homemade dough and sauce, finished with a 100% cheese blend. Sauce options include red or white.

Philly Steak

12'' Hoagie

Italian

all hoagies come with lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo, and dressing.

Steak

12'' Hoagie

Grilled Chicken

12'' Hoagie

Meatball

12'' Hoagie

Eggplant Parm

12'' Hoagie

Cheese

12'' Hoagie

Club (turkey, Ham & Bacon)

12'' Hoagie

Buffalo Chicken

12'' Hoagie

Chicken Parm

12'' Hoagie

Cheeseburger

12'' Hoagie

Hot Sausage

12'' Hoagie

Egg & Pepperoni

12'' Hoagie

Egg & Sweet Pepper

12'' Hoagie

Veggie

12'' Hoagie

Ham & Cheese

12'' Hoagie

All Meat Deluxe

A pizza packed with various meats, available in six different sizes, prepared with either an original or white base.

Buffalo Chicken Ranch

A perfect blend of buffalo chicken and ranch, topped with bacon, cheddar cheese, and choices of size and crust type that include small to X-Large, original or white.

Hawaiian

Red sauce and mozzarella, topped with Canadian-style ham and pineapple. Available in small, medium, large or X-large, and original or white preparation options.

Steak & Mushroom

Shaved Ribeye and seared mushrooms on original or white base, various sizes available.

Barbecue Chicken & Bacon

A tasteful fusion of tender barbecue chicken and crisp bacon, served on your choice of an original or white base. Available in a variety of sizes, each slice is bursting with flavors to savor.

Ricotta & Tomato

Ricotta and tomato pizza available in multiple sizes, with either original or white preparation.

Spinach & Ricotta

Enjoy our delicious pizza topped with spinach and creamy ricotta, available in Original, Small, Medium, Large, X-Large sizes and a White preparation option.

Greek

Greek-inspired pizza in different sizes with either white or original preparation.

Chicken Parmesan

Oven-baked chicken, marinara, mozzarella and parmesan cheese with choice of size and crust.

Cheeseburger & Bacon

Enjoy a savoury blend of ground beef, melted cheese, and crispy bacon layered on a choice of original or white dough. You can further customise it by choosing from four different sizes.

Philly Steak

Philly steak pizza available in medium (8 cut), large (10 cut), or X-Large (12 cut) sizes. Choose between original or white preparation. Specify pie size and preparation at order.

Pierogi

Savor the unexpected delight of our medium, 8 cut pierogi-style specialty pizza. Original or white pizza serves as the canvas for this unconventional yet irresistibly delicious Italian spin on a classic, preparing your palate for a delightful surprise.

Spinach & Tomato

Spinach and tomato specialty pizza with option for original or white preparation. Available in small, medium, large, or x-large.

Veggie

White or Original base, available in sizes: Small, Medium, Large or X-Large.

Meaty Wings

Meaty wings available in half or whole dozen, with choice of sauce: buffalo, bbq, seasoned salt, butter garlic, or garlic parm, extra sauce optional.

Provolone Wedges

Jalapeño Poppers

Fried Mushrooms

Breadsticks

Loaf Garlic Bread

12-inch Pepperoni Or Jalapeño Rolls

Enjoy our homemade rolls filled with your choice of spicy pepperoni or tangy jalapeño, a fun twist on a traditional favorite.

Chicken Tenders And Fries

Cheezy Garlic Toast

Garlic Toast

Chicken Caesar Salad

Comes with fries.

Club Salad

Small Salad

Super Salad

Greek Salad

Antipasto Salad

Buffalo Chicken Salad

Comes with fries.

Grilled Chicken Salad

Comes with fries.

Large Garden Salad

Pepperoni

Steak

Italian

Turkey

Tuna

Grilled Chicken

12'' hoagie

Philly Steak

Club

Ham

Veggie

Steak

Steak-filled Stromboli or Calzone, served with a side of sauce. Choose your preference upon order.

House (pepperoni And Sausage)

Enjoy our house-made Stromboli or Calzone, generously filled with pepperoni and sausage.

Pepperoni

This Italian delicacy offers a mouthwatering experience of stuffed crust filled with rich peppery flavors of pepperoni and delectably smooth mozzarella cheese, prepared either as a Calzone or Stromboli.

Cheese

Cheese-filled, choice of Stromboli or Calzone preparation.

Mushroom And Cheese

Mushroom and cheese, choice of Calzone or Stromboli preparation.

Meatball

Filled with savory meatballs and accompanied by a side of sauce. Choose your preparation as either a Calzone or a Stromboli.

Italian

An Italian delight, choose between a Stromboli or Calzone, each prepared with key flavors of mozzarella and pepperoni, served with a side of marinara sauce.

Veggie Combination

Veggie Combination with a choice of preparation as Calzone or Stromboli.

Spinach

Experience the delightful blend of mozzarella cheese and freshly prepared spinach, wrapped in a scrumptiously baked crust. Choose to have it in a Stromboli or a Calzone style for a distinct taste.

Half - Sicilian 8 Cut

Whole - Sicilian 16 Cut

Steak

Italian

all sandwiches served on our homemade seasoned square sliced focaccia bread with cheese, lettuce, tomato, onions, mayo or dressing, add the works 1.25

Turkey

Grilled Chicken

12'' hoagie

Grilled Chicken & Roasted Red Peppers

Ham

Gyros - Lamb And Beef

Wraps

Choice of turkey, grilled chicken, chicken Caesar, Italian, grilled steak or veggie wrapped tightly.

Penne & Marinara Sauce

Chicken Parmesan

Meatball Casserole And Pasta

Eggplant Parmesan

2-liter

20 Ounce

Can