Buttermaid Bakery

Name: Buttermaid Bakery
Address: 425 Boardman Canfield Rd, Boardman, OH, 44512, US
Telephone: (330) 758-5968
Price range: $

4.5 ★★★★★

$

Cuisine Type

Bakery

📋 Menu

Cookie Boxes

Chocolate Chip Cookies

1 dozen. Super soft, rich, gooey, sweet cream butter made, melt in your mouth gourmet chocolate chip cookies - think cookie dough - a truly unique cookie. Millions sent nationwide and overseas to our soldiers.

Price: $10.99

Sea Salted Caramel Chocolate Cookies

1 dozen. Super soft, gooey, and so intensely rich that they're almost impossible to describe. Think cookie dough. Creamy buttery vanilla caramel, sea salt, sweet cream buttery dough and gourmet chocolate, all married together in hand-crafted small batches. This truly unique sweet & salty indulgence is what you've been missing.

Price: $10.99

Peanut Butter Buckeyes

8 large buckeyes weighing in at over an ounce and half each! A super delicious peanut butter fudge ball covered in chocolate.

Price: $18.99

Cinnamon Pecan Kolachi Cookies

14-18 cookies. Our cinnamon pecan cookies are a nostalgic taste somewhere between warm cinnamon rolls and those cinnamon sugar pecans we used to buy in the center of the mall at holidays. We take fresh ground Georgia pecans, brown sugar and real cinnamon to make our filling. The cookie dough is made with real butter and sour cream, wraps the filling and is sprinkled with cinnamon sugar. A sweet crunch on the outside and then melts in your mouth. If you're familiar with the best selling, traditional walnut or apricot kolachi cookies, we're not afraid to say... we think these are better ????

Price: $24.99

Sugar Butter Cookies

Approx. 1 dozen per 12 oz box. Simple. Honest. Anything but plain. They're incredibly soft and buttery. You've had your share of sugar cookies, but you have not had THIS sugar cookie. Made with the world's finest Madagascar pure vanilla.

Price: $10.99

Nut Kolachi Cookies Aka Kolacky, Kolaczki, Kiffles

Now a larger quantity of 14-18 cookies. Our real butter and sour cream dough cookies with the same filling as the large rolls, made with fresh ground California grown English walnuts delivered directly from the farm. Best seller!

Price: $24.99

Chocolate Drizzled Coconut Macaroons

Our macaroons with tender shredded coconut and real sugar are baked to golden perfection for a chewy outside and super moist & soft center. Rich, dark chocolate coats the bottom and is drizzled on top for a sweet & delicious treat.What You Get: Approximately 14 macaroons per 10 oz box.

Price: $18.99

Butterballs - Toasted Walnut Cookies

1 dozen. A super delicious, melt in your mouth, shortbread type butter cookie with hand chopped toasted walnuts. Tossed in confectioner's powdered sugar.

Price: $18.99

Chocolate Rum Balls

2 Dozen. Try our delicious new rum flavored chocolate confection. They're sweet, a little chewy, and disappear fast. Coated in chocolate & sprinkles.What You Get: Approximately 24 rum balls per 12 oz box.

Price: $18.99

Raspberry Kolachi Cookies Aka Kolacky, Kolaczki, Kiffles

Now a larger quantity of 14-18 cookies. Plump, juicy red raspberry jam joined with our sweet cream butter & sour cream dough to deliver a slightly sweet & tart cookie that disappears fast.

Price: $24.99

Apricot Kolachi Cookies Aka Kolacky, Kolaczki, Kiffles

Now a larger quantity of 14-18 cookies. Deliciously sweet & slightly tart, gooey apricot butter filling inside our sweet cream butter and sour cream dough cookie. Yum!

Price: $24.99

Italian Rainbow Cake Bites

2 Dozen, Over 1 lb! Try our delicious traditional Italian rainbow cake bites. Layers of moist almond cake with raspberry jam, coated in rich, dark chocolate & sprinkles. Try to eat just one. These iconic and festive treats are popular for all holidays and a fixture of Christmas dessert tables. They go by different names or variations such as Petit Fours or even cookies, although they are really a cake... Italian Rainbow Cookies, Tricolor Cookies or Neopolitan Cookies.What You Get: Approximately 24 cake bites per 16 oz box.Allergens: Contains wheat, egg, soy & milk. Our bakery uses peanuts and tree nuts. Color added.

Price: $22.99

Patriotic Sprinkle Sugar Butter Cookies

1 dozen. Indulge in our super soft and delicious patriotic sprinkle sugar butter cookie. It takes our regular sugar butter cookie to the next level with white chocolate, brown sugar, sweet cream butter and the best Madagascar Bourbon pure vanilla. Red, white and blue sprinkles bring the fun in this patriotic treat that is tasty anytime, and perfect for the summer BBQ.

Price: $10.99

Clothespin Cookies Aka Lady Locks, Fingers, Cream Horns

NEW larger size clothespins. 12-14 per 10 oz box. Melt in your mouth, super delicious, sweet buttercream filled, flaky, yet soft, fluffy pastry, dusted with confectioners powdered sugar.

Price: $24.99

Birthday Cake Confetti Cookies

1 dozen. Sprinkles bring the party and an automatic happiness with every birthday cake flavored, incredibly soft bite. It's a sweet-cream butter based dough with white chocolate chips and the finest Madagascar pure vanilla.

Price: $10.99

Cookie Mounds

Chocolate Chip Mound

Insanely large 7 oz cookie. Super soft, rich, gooey, sweet cream butter made, melt in your mouth gourmet chocolate chip cookie mound - think cookie dough - a truly unique cookie. We suggest a tall ice-cold glass of milk, and a nap.

Price: $5.99

M&m Chocolate Chip Mound

Insanely large 7 oz cookie. Super soft, rich, gooey, sweet cream butter made, melt in your mouth M&M chocolate chip cookie mound - think cookie dough - a truly unique cookie. We suggest a tall ice-cold glass of milk, and a nap.

Price: $5.99

Sea Salted Caramel Chocolate Mounds

Insanely large 7 oz cookie. Super soft, gooey, and intensely rich. Think cookie dough. Creamy buttery vanilla caramel, sea salt, sweet cream buttery dough and gourmet chocolate. We suggest a tall ice-cold glass of milk, and a nap.

Price: $5.99

Kolachi Nut Rolls

The Original Nut Kolachi Roll

The original old world recipe! Rich, sweet & creamy fresh ground walnut filling, and sweet cream buttery dough. Yum! Large 24 oz roll, about 14" long. Sealed packaging for optimum freshness, freezer storage, and gifting. May arrive chilled. Slice to preferred thickness, about 18-28 slices, and serve room temp or warm.

Price: $18.99

Pecan Kolachi Roll

Fresh ground Georgia pecans, brown sugar, real cinnamon, sweet cream buttery dough. Pure pecan perfection! Large 24 oz roll, about 14" long. Sealed packaging for optimum freshness, freezer storage, and gifting. May arrive chilled. Slice to preferred thickness, about 18-28 slices, and serve room temp or warm.

Price: $18.99

Honey Walnut Kolachi Roll

Sweet honey & fresh ground California walnuts combined for a rich, sweet & creamy filling. Yum! Large 24 oz roll, about 14" long. Sealed packaging for optimum freshness, freezer storage, and gifting. May arrive chilled. Slice to preferred thickness, about 18-28 slices, and serve room temp or warm.

Price: $18.99

Apricot Filled Kolachi Roll

Deliciously sweet & slightly tart, gooey apricot butter rolled into our sweet cream buttery dough. Yum!Large 24 oz roll, about 14" long. Sealed packaging for optimum freshness, freezer storage, and gifting. May arrive chilled. Slice to preferred thickness, about 18-28 slices, and serve room temp or warm.

Price: $18.99

Lemon Cream Kolachi Roll

Deliciously sweet & tart lemon cream, perfectly balanced inside sweet cream buttery dough. Exceptionally refreshing! Large 24 oz roll, about 14" long. Sealed packaging for optimum freshness, freezer storage, and gifting. May arrive chilled. Slice to preferred thickness, about 18-28 slices, and serve room temp or warm.

Price: $18.99

Reduced Sugar Walnut Kolachi Roll

40% less sugar than the original walnut kolachi! Organic stevia delivers a perfect balance of great taste & less sugar! Large 24 oz roll, about 14" long. Sealed packaging for optimum freshness, freezer storage, and gifting. May arrive chilled. Slice to preferred thickness, about 18-28 slices, and serve room temp or warm.

Price: $18.99

Cream Cheese Kolachi Roll

Swirls of sweet, rich, buttery, creamy filling, so decadent and truly unique in our sweet cream buttery dough. Yum! Large 24 oz roll, about 14" long. Sealed packaging for optimum freshness, freezer storage, and gifting. May arrive chilled. Slice to preferred thickness, about 18-28 slices, and serve room temp or warm.

Price: $18.99

Apple Cinnamon Walnut Kolachi Roll

Real apples & cinnamon, fresh ground walnuts, secret apple pie spice blend, and sweet cream buttery dough. Oh MY! Large 24 oz roll, about 14" long. Sealed packaging for optimum freshness, freezer storage, and gifting. May arrive chilled. Slice to preferred thickness, about 18-28 slices, and serve room temp or warm.

Price: $18.99

Apple Cinnamon Jam Kolachi Roll

Heavenly artisanal jam of ripe, juicy, sweet apples & real cinnamon, in sweet cream buttery pastry. Staff favorite! Large 24 oz roll, about 14" long. Sealed packaging for optimum freshness, freezer storage, and gifting. May arrive chilled. Slice to preferred thickness, about 18-28 slices, and serve room temp or warm.

Price: $18.99

Walnut & Raisin Filled Kolachi Roll

Plump & juicy raisins, sweet & creamy walnut filling, rolled into our sweet cream buttery dough. Yum! Large 24 oz roll, about 14" long. Sealed packaging for optimum freshness, freezer storage, and gifting. May arrive chilled. Slice to preferred thickness, about 18-28 slices, and serve room temp or warm.

Price: $18.99

Poppy Seed & Raisin Filled Kolachi Roll

Plump & juicy raisins, slightly nutty, bitter sweet poppy seed filling, rolled into sweet cream buttery dough. Yum! Large 24 oz roll, about 14" long. Sealed packaging for optimum freshness, freezer storage, and gifting. May arrive chilled. Slice to preferred thickness, about 18-28 slices, and serve room temp or warm.

Price: $18.99

Raspberry Jam Kolachi Roll

A delectable small batch artisanal jam of plump, juicy red raspberries wrapped in sweet cream buttery dough. Breakfast favorite! Large 24 oz roll, about 14" long. Sealed packaging for optimum freshness, freezer storage, and gifting. May arrive chilled. Slice to preferred thickness, about 18-28 slices, and serve room temp or warm.

Price: $18.99

Prune Lekvar Filled Kolachi Roll

Deliciously sweet & tart, creamy prune butter “lekvar” rolled into our sweet cream buttery dough. Yum! Large 24 oz roll, about 14" long. Sealed packaging for optimum freshness, freezer storage, and gifting. May arrive chilled. Slice to preferred thickness, about 18-28 slices, and serve room temp or warm.

Price: $18.99

Chocolate Walnut Kolachi Roll

The finest Royal Dutch cocoa & fresh ground walnuts combined for a rich, sweet & creamy filling. Yum! Large 24 oz roll, about 14" long. Sealed packaging for optimum freshness, freezer storage, and gifting. May arrive chilled. Slice to preferred thickness, about 18-28 slices, and serve room temp or warm.

Price: $18.99

Blueberry Jam Kolachi Roll

Luscious artisanal blueberry jam in soft buttery pastry, a sweet & tangy burst of wild Maine blueberries in every bite! Large 24 oz roll, about 14" long. Sealed packaging for optimum freshness, freezer storage, and gifting. May arrive chilled. Slice to preferred thickness, about 18-28 slices, and serve room temp or warm.

Price: $18.99

Raspberry Walnut Kolachi Roll

Plump juicy red raspberries & fresh ground walnuts combined for a rich, sweet & creamy filling. Yum! Large 24 oz roll, about 14" long. Sealed packaging for optimum freshness, freezer storage, and gifting. May arrive chilled. Slice to preferred thickness, about 18-28 slices, and serve room temp or warm.

Price: $18.99

Pies

Cherry Crumb Pie - 9"

Cherry pie with our signature crispy crumb topping. 9" deep dish, over 3 pound pie serves 8-10. FROZEN ITEM; baked fresh & frozen. To serve quickly, warm in 425 degree oven for 20-30 minutes. Thaw in refrigerator overnight or room temp several hours before serving.

Price: $23.99

Blueberry Crumb Pie - 9"

Blueberry pie with our signature crispy crumb topping. 9" deep dish, over 3 pound pie serves 8-10. FROZEN ITEM; baked fresh & frozen. To serve quickly, warm in 425 degree oven for 20-30 minutes. Thaw in refrigerator overnight or room temp several hours before serving.

Price: $23.99

Apple Crumb Pie - 9"

Apple pie with our signature crispy crumb topping. 9" deep dish, over 3 pound pie serves 8-10. FROZEN ITEM; baked fresh & frozen. To serve quickly, warm in 425 degree oven for 20-30 minutes. Thaw in refrigerator overnight or room temp several hours before serving.

Price: $23.99

Peach Crumb Pie - 9"

Peach pie with our signature crispy crumb topping. 9" deep dish, over 3 pound pie serves 8-10. FROZEN ITEM; baked fresh & frozen. To serve quickly, warm in 425 degree oven for 20-30 minutes. Thaw in refrigerator overnight or room temp several hours before serving.

Price: $23.99

Extras

Kolachi Slicing Knife

11" plastic bread knife for slicing kolachi on the go.

Price: $0.99

Buttermaid Bakery

Cuisine Type

📍 Location & Contact

🕒 Hours & Details

Hours

Restaurant Details

📋 Menu

Cookie Boxes

Chocolate Chip Cookies

Sea Salted Caramel Chocolate Cookies

Peanut Butter Buckeyes

Cinnamon Pecan Kolachi Cookies

Sugar Butter Cookies

Nut Kolachi Cookies Aka Kolacky, Kolaczki, Kiffles

Chocolate Drizzled Coconut Macaroons

Butterballs - Toasted Walnut Cookies

Chocolate Rum Balls

Raspberry Kolachi Cookies Aka Kolacky, Kolaczki, Kiffles

Apricot Kolachi Cookies Aka Kolacky, Kolaczki, Kiffles

Italian Rainbow Cake Bites

Patriotic Sprinkle Sugar Butter Cookies

Clothespin Cookies Aka Lady Locks, Fingers, Cream Horns

Birthday Cake Confetti Cookies

Cookie Mounds

Chocolate Chip Mound

M&m Chocolate Chip Mound

Sea Salted Caramel Chocolate Mounds

Kolachi Nut Rolls

The Original Nut Kolachi Roll

Pecan Kolachi Roll

Honey Walnut Kolachi Roll

Apricot Filled Kolachi Roll

Lemon Cream Kolachi Roll

Reduced Sugar Walnut Kolachi Roll

Cream Cheese Kolachi Roll

Apple Cinnamon Walnut Kolachi Roll

Apple Cinnamon Jam Kolachi Roll

Walnut & Raisin Filled Kolachi Roll

Poppy Seed & Raisin Filled Kolachi Roll

Raspberry Jam Kolachi Roll

Prune Lekvar Filled Kolachi Roll

Chocolate Walnut Kolachi Roll

Blueberry Jam Kolachi Roll

Raspberry Walnut Kolachi Roll

Pies

Cherry Crumb Pie - 9"

Blueberry Crumb Pie - 9"

Apple Crumb Pie - 9"

Peach Crumb Pie - 9"

Extras

Kolachi Slicing Knife

📍 Nearby Restaurants

Kabob House

Havana House

Cornersburg Pizza

Uncle Nicks Greek Fried Chicken

Explore More

🍽️ More Bakery in Boardman