Bagelry
Cuisine Type
📍 Location & Contact
🕒 Hours & Details
Restaurant Details
📋 Menu
Beverages
Apple Juice
Tropicana
Bru Bros. Nitro Cold Brew Coffee (12 Oz.)
From Bru Brothers, local Cincinnati coffee brewers and enthusiasts.
Bru Bros. Cold Brew Bottled Coffee
From Bru Brothers, local Cincinnati coffee brewers and enthusiasts.
Milk
Horizon organic, 8 oz. carton
La Croix Seltzer Water
12 oz. can
Coffee - Large (16 Oz.)
Tinker Coffee Indianapolis, Single Origin Nicaragua
Orange Juice
Tropicana Low Pulp
Hot Chocolate (12 Oz.)
Coffee Box
96 oz. cardboard coffee clutch. Single Origin, Malawi, Tinker Coffee, Indianapolis, IN
Bottled Tea - Sweetened
Coke
12 oz. can
Bottled Cold Brew Coffee
From Bru Bros, 12 oz. bottle
Bottled Tea
18.5 oz. bottle
Milk
Horizon Organic, 8 oz. carton
Hot Chocolate
Hot Tea
Sprite
Diet Coke
La Croix
Nitro Cold Brew Coffee
From Bru Bros, 12 oz. cup
Egg Sandwiches
Queen City
Fresh cracked scrambled egg, Glier's goetta, and American cheese on your choice of bagel. If you'd like to make substitutions, please instead choose the BYO Breakfast and customize away! Breakfast sandwiches are "toasted" by default. Please only select Double Toasted if you like your bagel very dark.
Southwestern
Fresh cracked scrambled egg, Avril Bleh sausage, pepperjack cheese, jalapeno garlic cream cheese, banana peppers, and red onions on your choice of bagel. If you'd like to make substitutions, please instead choose the BYO Breakfast and customize away!
The Garden
Fresh crackled scrambled egg, Swiss cheese, roasted vegetable cream cheese, lettuce, onion, tomato, and red bell pepper on your choice of bagel. If you'd like to make substitutions, please instead choose the BYO Breakfast and customize away! Breakfast sandwiches are "toasted" by default. Please only select Double Toasted if you like your bagel very dark.
Bacon Avocado
Egg, bacon, avocado, and sriracha on your choice of bagel. If you'd like to make substitutions, please instead choose the BYO Breakfast and customize away! Breakfast sandwiches are "toasted" by default. Please only select Double Toasted if you like your bagel very dark.
Byo Breakfast
Fresh cracked scrambled egg on your choice of bagel. Option to add cheese, meat, and/or veggies! *We'll do our best to accommodate your bagel flavor, but please note that we run out of certain flavors during the day and may default to a plain bagel if we're out of your selected flavor. Breakfast sandwiches are "toasted" by default. Please only select Double Toasted if you like your bagel very dark.
The Gecco
Goetta, Egg, Cheddar, and Chive & Onion cream cheese on your choice of bagel. If you'd like to make substitutions, please instead choose the BYO Breakfast and customize away! Breakfast sandwiches are "toasted" by default. Please only select Double Toasted if you like your bagel very dark.
The Skillet
A whole diner breakfast piled on a bagel! Fresh cracked scrambled egg, bacon, American cheese, a hash brown, and ketchup on your choice of bagel.
Cuban Breakfast
Fresh cracked scrambled egg, ham, Swiss cheese, plain cream cheese, dill, Dijon mustard, and pickles on your choice of bagel.
Byo Breakfast
Build-your-own style! Fresh cracked scrambled egg on your choice of bagel, with option to add cheese, protein, and/or veggies. *Our egg sandwiches run through a conveyor oven by default, so only select toasted or double toasted if you'd like your bagel toasted first before running through the oven.
Queen City
Fresh cracked scrambled egg, Glier's goetta, and American cheese on your choice of bagel. If you would like to make substitutions, please create your own bagel sandwich instead.
Southwestern
Fresh cracked scrambled egg, Avril Bleh sausage, pepperjack cheese, jalapeno garlic cream cheese, banana peppers, and red onions on your choice of bagel. If you would like to make substitutions, please create your own bagel sandwich instead.
The Garden
Bacon Avocado
The Gecco
Bagel Sandwiches
Avocado Bagel Toast
Sliced avocado, sea salt, red pepper flakes, onion, and tomato on your choice of bagel.
Blt
Double bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo on your choice of bagel.
Pizza Bagel
Garlic butter, pizza sauce, provolone, and Italian seasoning. Option to add pepperoni and/or banana peppers. *We'll do our best to accommodate your bagel flavor, but please note that we run out of certain flavors during the day and may default to a plain bagel if we're out of your selected flavor.
Italian
Ham, pepperoni, jalapeno garlic cream cheese, onion, tomato, and banana peppers. *We'll do our best to accommodate your bagel flavor, but please note that we run out of certain flavors during the day and may default to a plain bagel if we're out of your selected flavor.
Smoked Turkey Club
Lucius Q smoked turkey, lettuce, tomato, onion, and bacon scallion cream cheese. *We'll do our best to accommodate your bagel flavor, but please note that we run out of certain flavors during the day and may default to a plain bagel if we're out of your selected flavor.
Nyc Lox
Brooklyn-based Acme lox, onion, tomato, capers, and plain cream cheese. *We'll do our best to accommodate your bagel flavor, but please note that we run out of certain flavors during the day and may default to a plain bagel if we're out of your selected flavor.
Smoked Turkey
Lucius Q smoked turkey, housemade onion chive cream cheese, lettuce, and tomato on your choice of bagel. Option to add bacon for the full club experience!
Tuna Salad
Our house-made tuna salad, lettuce, and tomato on your choice of bagel.
Bagels
Bagel & Cream Cheese
One of our housemade spreads on your choice of bagel.
Half Dozen Bagels
6 hand-rolled, cold-proofed, kettle-boiled bagels of your choice. Please indicate in the text field below what count of each bagel flavor you'd like, and a few backup flavors in case we've run out.We will do our best to accommodate or communicate with you if we are out of flavors. We can only accommodate up to 2 dozen bagels via online ordering. If you need to order more than that, please email [email protected] to place your order.
Dozen Bagels
12 hand-rolled, cold-proofed, kettle-boiled bagels of your choice. Please indicate in the text field below what count of each bagel flavor you'd like, and a few backup flavors in case we've run out.We will do our best to accommodate or communicate with you if we are out of certain flavors. We can only accommodate up to 2 dozen bagels via online ordering. If you need to order more than that, please email [email protected] to place your order.
Single Bagel
Bagel, plain and simple, with options to slice and toast.*If you'd like butter, please choose bagel & butter. If you'd like cream cheese, please choose bagel & cream cheese. If you'd like egg, please choose egg sandwich.
Brunch Bundle
12 hand-rolled, cold-proofed, kettle-boiled bagels of your choice + 2 tubs of housemade cream cheese. Please indicate in the text field below what count of each bagel flavor you'd like, and a few backup flavors in case we've run out.We will do our best to accommodate or communicate with you if we are out of certain flavors. We can only accommodate up to 2 brunch bundles via online ordering. If you need to order more than that, please email [email protected] to place your order.
Bagel & Butter
Freshly baked bagel with butter.
Sandwiches
Smoked Turkey Club
Lucius Q smoked turkey, bacon scallion cream cheese, lettuce, tomato, and onion on your choice of bagel.
Pizza Bagel
Garlic butter, pizza sauce, and provolone on your choice of bagel. Option to add pepperoni and/or banana peppers.
Italian Sandwich
Ham, pepperoni, banana peppers, onion, tomato, and jalapeno garlic cream cheese on your choice of bagel.
Nyc Lox
Lox straight from Brooklyn on your choice of bagel with plain cream cheese, capers, onions, and tomatoes.
Avocado Bagel Toast
Fresh sliced avocado on your choice of bagel with lemon juice, sea salt, red pepper flakes, onion, and tomato.
Blt
Bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo on your choice of bagel.
Vegan Picnic Salad Naked
Custom *no Egg* Sandwich
Bagels & Spreads
Single Bagel
*We'll do our best to accommodate your bagel flavor, but please note that we run out of certain flavors during the day.
Dozen Bagels
Please indicate in the Notes section during Checkout which counts of each bagel you'd like. We'll do our best to accommodate but please be aware that we may run out of bagels and substitute with other flavors.
Brunch Bundle
A dozen bagels with 2 tubs of cream cheese. Please indicate in the Notes section during Checkout which counts of each bagel you'd like. We'll do our best to accommodate but please be aware that we may run out of bagels and substitute with other flavors.
Single Bagel & Spread
*We'll do our best to accommodate your bagel flavor, but please note that we run out of certain flavors during the day. If you'd like a bagel with butter, please select 'Single Bagel' and add Butter.
Half Dozen Bagels
Please indicate in the Notes section during Checkout which counts of each bagel you'd like. We'll do our best to accommodate but please be aware that we may run out of bagels and substitute with other flavors.
Bagel And Butter
Vegan Spread (8 Oz.)
8 oz. tub of our housemade vegan cashew spread.
Cream Cheese (8 Oz.)
8 oz. tub of our housemade cream cheese.
Sides
Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie
A Massachusetts original brought to the next level in Cincinnati using premium chocolate and browned butter.
Superfood Salad - Small
Kale, carrots, red peppers, dried cherries, almonds, Cotija cheese, and citrus Dijon vinaigrette on the side.
Superfood Salad - Large
Kale, carrots, red peppers, dried cherries, almonds, Cotija cheese, and citrus Dijon vinaigrette on the side.
Miss Vickie's Chips
2 Oz. Lox
A single portion of lox from Acme in Brooklyn, NY.
Miss Vickie's Chips
Bagel Chips
Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie
Lox - 2 Oz. Portion
Specials
Bengals Bagels - Half Dozen
WHO DEY! 6 of our Bengal stripe bagels.
Reuben
Premium pastrami, Swiss, sauerkraut, and Thousand Island dressing served warm on your choice of bagel. We suggest pumpernickel!
Mediterranean
Fresh cracked scrambled egg, sausage patty, tzatziki cream cheese, red onions, and tomato on your choice of bagel.
Pumpkin + Vanilla Cream Cheese
Our signature fall pumpkin bagel with our housemade vanilla cream cheese. Try the pumpkin pie add-ons!
Merch
5x7 Print
A variety of 5x7 prints available from local artist Stephanie Smith. Check out her work here: https://www.instagram.com/stephaniesmithcreative/.
T Shirt
Gray t-shirt with turquoise bagel-patterned pocket. Available in small, medium, large, extra large.
Creatures Real And Imagined
Zine, written and illustrated by Stephanie Smith
Common
12 Oz. Coffee
Tinker Coffee Indianapolis, Single Origin Honduras
16 Oz. Coffee
Tinker Coffee Indianapolis, Single Origin Honduras
Test
Salads
Superfood Salad
Kale, red bell peppers, carrots, almonds, dried cherries, Cotija cheese, and citrus dijon vinaigrette.
Spreads
8 Oz. Spread
An 8-ounce container of one of our housemade spreads.