Utica Pie Co.

Upside Down Pie

Sauce on top of mozzarella.

Catherine Street

White pie with fresh roasted garlic, mozzarella, ricotta, and seasoned crust.

Pellettieri Ave

Upc's Margherita pie with san marzano tomatoes, burrata cheese and fresh basil.

Utica Pie Small

Our famous tomato pie topped with fresh grated cheese. (Mozzarella is not on this pie).

Bleecker Street

Pepperoni, sausage, meatball (upside down).

Albany Street

Broccoli rabe, roasted garlic, sausage (spicy), mozzarella, fresh ricotta cheese.

Jay Street

Upc's Buffalo chicken pie. Chunks of breaded chicken breast tossed in our delicious sauce.(4) Bleu cheese or ranch included.

Utica Pie Large

Our famous tomato pie topped with fresh grated cheese. (Mozzarella is not on this pie).

Albany Street Small

Broccoli rabe, roasted garlic, sausage (spicy), mozzarella, fresh ricotta cheese.

Pellettieri Ave Small

Upc's Margherita pie with san marzano tomatoes, burrata cheese and fresh basil.

Catherine Street Small

White pie with fresh roasted garlic, mozzarella, ricotta, and seasoned crust.

Upside Down Pie Small

Mozzarella underneath sauce.

Jay Street Small

Upc's Buffalo chicken pie. Chunks of breaded chicken breast tossed in our delicious sauce.(3) Bleu cheese or ranch included.

South Street Small

Upc's spicy BBQ chicken pie. Chunks of breaded chicken breast, red onion and mozzarella with burrata tossed in our house-made spicy bbq sauce.

Bleecker Street Small

Pepperoni, sausage, meatball (upside down).

South Street

Upc's spicy BBQ chicken pie. Chunks of breaded chicken breast, red onion and mozzarella with burrata tossed in our house-made spicy bbq sauce.

Large Pie & 20 Wings

Large pie with mozzarella and 20 Buffalo wings.

Small Pie & 10 Wings

Small pie with mozzarella and 10 Buffalo wings.

2 Large Pies & 50 Wings

2 large pies with mozzarella and 50 Buffalo wings.

Buffalo Wings 10

Buffalo-style chicken wings tossed in your choice of house sauces.

Buffalo Wings 20

Buffalo-style chicken wings tossed in your choice of house sauces.

Buffalo Wings 30

Buffalo-style chicken wings tossed in your choice of house sauces.

Buffalo Wings 40

Buffalo-style chicken wings tossed in your choice of house sauces.

Buffalo Wings 50

Buffalo-style chicken wings tossed in your choice of house sauces.

Buffalo Wings 100

Buffalo-style chicken wings tossed in your choice of house sauces.

Large 1/2 Topping Pie

Please select your 1/2 toppings for each side.

Small 2 Topping Pie

Please select 2 toppings.

Large Plain Pie

Large pie with mozzarella.

Large 1 Topping Pie

Please select 1 topping.

Large 2 Topping Pie

Please select 2 toppings.

Large 3 Topping Pie

Please select 3 toppings.

Large Plain White Pie

Large pie brushed with EVOO, fresh grated cheese, ricotta and mozzarella.

Large Plain Pie (thin Crust)

Large thin crust pie with mozzarella.

Small Plain Pie

Small pie with mozzarella.

Small 1/2 Topping Pie

Small 1 Topping Pie

Please select 1 topping.

Small 3 Topping Pie

Please select 3 toppings.

Small Plain Pie (thin Crust)

Small thin crust pie with mozzarella.

Small Plain White Pie

Large pie brushed with EVOO, fresh grated cheese ricotta and mozzarella.

Large 4+ Topping Pie

Please select 4 or more toppings.

Small 4+ Topping Pie

Please select 4 or more toppings.

Caesar Salad

UPC's family sized classic Caesar with fresh shaved Parmesan.

Boylan Fountain Cola (20oz)

Boylan Fountain Creamy Red Birch Beer (20oz)

Boylan Fountain Ginger Ale (20oz)

Boylan Fountain Sweet Tea (20oz)

Boylan Fountain Lemonade (20oz)

Boylan Fountain Black Cherry (20oz)