Whit's Frozen Custard

Custard Sandwich 6-pack

6 of our custard sandwiches

2 Pack Of Cookies

Custard Sandwich

Our famous custard sandwiched between 2 chocolate wafers.

Doggie Sundae / Pup Cup

For your furry friend: vanilla custard with peanut butter and a dog bone

Drumstick

Favorite.

Frozen Custard - Quart

Choose from our most popular quart flavors!

Italian Ice

An single cup of our delicious Italian Ice (vegan, gluten free & dairy free) - choose your flavor!

Chocolate Covered Banana

A frozen banana dipped in chocolate with optional nuts or sprinkles.

Whitties

A generous scoop of our delicious frozen custard, between two store baked cookies, then frozen to perfection.

Cones

Add a 4-pack of waffle cones to your order.

Birthday Cake Whittie - New!

A scoop of our famous vanilla custard between 2 birthday cake cookies.

Chocolate Chip Vanilla Whittie - Best Seller!

2 store baked chocolate chip cookies filled with a generous scoop of Whit's vanilla custard then frozen to perfection! This is our most popular Whittie.

Surprise Me With Any Flavor Whittie

We make a lot of different whitties flavors. We will surprise you with any whittie from our case - it could be something new and you will discover a new favorite!

Peanut Butter Buckeye Whittie - Customer Favorite!

2 store baked peanut butter cookies filled with a generous scoop of our popular buckeye custard. Perfect for a game day treat!

M&m Vanilla Whittie

We take 2 specialty store-baked M&M cookies and fill with our creamy vanilla custard.

Chocolate Filled Chocolate Chip Whittie

Chocolate Lovers Dream - 2 store baked chocolate chip cookies filled with a generous scoop of Whit's Chocolate custard then frozen to perfection!

Oatmeal Raisin Whittie

This classic whittie combines 2 store-baked oatmeal raisin cookies with a generous scoop of Whit's vanilla custard.

S'mores Whittie

It's our version of the campfire classic - 2 store baked S'mores cookies filled with a generous scoop of Whit's vanilla custard then we add chocolate drizzle coating and freeze!

Double Dark Chocolate Whittie

2 store baked double dark chocolate chip cookies filled with a generous scoop of Whit's chocolate custard then frozen to perfection!

Sugar Sprinkle Whittie

We take 2 store baked sugar cookies, fill with a generous scoop of Whit's vanilla custard then we roll in rainbow or seasonal sprinkles. Fun Item Alert!

Frozen Drumstick - Popular Item!

2 scoops of custard on a waffle cone, dipped in chocolate coating then topped with your choice of extra chocolate, rainbow/seasonal sprinkles or chopped nuts. Served frozen!

Custard Sandwich

Choose from chocolate or vanilla custard between 2 chocolate wafers then frozen to perfection!

Frozen Chocolate Banana

A full size banana on a stick, dipped in chocolate then coated with your choice of more chocolate, nuts or sprinkles

Oreo Sandwich - New Item!

We take a scoop of our famous vanilla custard and sandwich it between 2 jumbo Oreo wafers, then we freeze to perfection!

Custard Sandwich 6pk - Great Group Treat!

Perfect group treat for home of the office! A 6-pack container with your choice of 6 vanilla filled custard sandwiches or 3 chocolate filled/3 vanilla filled custard sandwiches.

Cookie Lovers Box

1 Quart of Chocolate. 1 Quart of Vanilla. Toppings cups include cookie dough, cookies & crème, rainbow sprinkles & chocolate syrup, plus 8 serving cups in a convenient party box.

Birthday Party Box

1 Quart of Chocolate. 1 Quart of Vanilla. Toppings cups include rainbow sprinkles, M&M's, gummy worms & chocolate syrup, plus 8 serving cups in a convenient party box.

Buckeye Game Day Party Pack

2 Quarts of Buckeye Custard. Topping cups include: Reese'e Cups, Reese's Pieces, Chocolate Syrup & Peanut Butter packed with 8 serving cups in a convenient party box.

Game Day Party Box

Includes a quart of chocolate, a quart of vanilla and 4 topping cups to include cookie dough bites, reese'e cups, sprinkles and peanut butter, along with 8 serving cups.

Chocolate Lovers Box

2 Quart of Chocolate Custard. Toppings cups include chocolate flakes, brownie bites, chocolate sprinkles & chocolate syrup, plus 8 serving cups in a convenient party box.

Candy Lovers Party Pack

2 Quarts of Vanilla Custard Topping cups include: Heath Bar, Snickers, M&Ms & Butterfinger packed with 8 serving cups in a convenient party box.

Cookies 'n Creme Custard Pie

Graham cracker pie crust filled with vanilla custard, topped with whip cream, cookies & cream and chocolate syrup

Buckeye Madness Custard Pie

Graham cracker pie crust filled with vanilla custard, topped with whip cream, peanut butter, chopped Reeces cups and chocolate syrup

Small Buckeye Madness Cake

Our most popular cake - buckeye madness. We combine vanilla custard with fudge, peanut butter, Reese's cups, chocolate syrup and whipped cream. Our small cake feeds 6-8. Keep cake frozen then allow to thaw approximately 20 minutes prior to serving.

Large Buckeye Madness Cake

Our most popular cake - buckeye madness. We combine vanilla custard with fudge, peanut butter, Reese's cups, chocolate syrup and whipped cream. Our large cake feeds 8-10+. Keep cake frozen then allow to thaw approximately 20 minutes prior to serving.

Butter Pecan Quart

This one is a classic - its our butterscotch custard mixed with roasted pecan halves.

Vanilla Quart - Most Loved!

A quart of our famous rich & creamy vanilla custard. Great item for pairing with your cake, pie or soda!

Cookies 'n Creme Quart

So simple yet so delicious. We mix cookies & creme pieces with our vanilla custard.

Almond Joy Quart

Our take on the famous candy bar. It's our toasted coconut custard mixed with roasted almonds, dark chocolate flakes and toasted coconut.

Black Raspberry Chip Quart

We blend our black raspberry custard with dark chocolate flakes. It's easy to see why this is one of our best selling flavors.

Van

Red Velvet Cake Quart

We mix real red velvet cake pieces and cream cheese frosting into our vanilla custard to create the perfect combination for all you red velvet cake lovers!

Chocolate Quart - Popular Item

A quart of our dreamy chocolate custard

Buckeye Quart - Customer Favorite!

One of our most popular flavors - our peanut butter custard mixed with Reese's peanut butter cups and peanut butter to create a perfect combo for game day or any special event!

Vanilla Chocolate Chip - Most Popular!

2 store baked chocolate chip cookies filled with a generous scoop of Whit's vanilla custard then frozen to perfection! This is our most popular Whittie.

Mint Chocolate Chip Quart

You'll easily see why this is a best seller - it's our mint flavored custard mixed with dark chocolate flakes.

Mud Pie Quart

We take our coffee flavored custard and mix it with cookies & creme pieces and add caramel swirls for a pefect coffee inspired treat!

Valentine Pack

1) quart of chocolate custard (1) quart of vanilla custard (4) cups of toppings: chocolate flakes, cherries, cheesecake bites, and chocolate syrup.