Sutter's Mill of Suffern Inc

Sutters Famous Buffalo Wings (6 Times Winner Of Rockland County Wing Fest)

Served with blue cheese & celery. Sauces: buffalo, BBQ, ginger teriyaki, Thai chili, garlic Parmesan, JD BBQ, old bay, mango habanero, & sriracha honey mustard.

Crock Of Wing Sauce

50 Wings

75 Wings

Crock Of Blue Cheese

100 Wings

Onion Rings

Bang Bang Shrimp (8)

Tossed in a creamy Thai chili sriracha sauce.

Fried Pickles

Served with creamy chipotle sauce.

"the Old" Steak Fries

Mozzarella Sticks (6)

Served with marinara sauce.

Hand-cut Fries

Bangin Brussels

Fried and topped with bacon, shaved parmesan, creamy horseradish sauce, and balsamic glaze.

Hand-cut Garlic Parm Fries

Tossed in garlic butter and topped with shaved & grated Parmesan cheese & served with side of creamy chipotle sauce.

Potato Skins

With cheese & side of sour cream. Add chili, bacon or broccoli for an additional charge.

Spring Rolls (4)

Served with duck sauce.

Chicken Potstickers

Served with homemade ginger teriyaki sauce.

Waffle Fries

Chicken Fingers

Add French fries for an additional charge.

Frings (fries & Onion Rings)

Zucchini Sticks

Served with marinara sauce.

Sweet Potato Fries

Garlic Bread Parm

With mozzarella cheese and side of marinara sauce.

Nachos Supreme

Choice of chili, pulled chicken or pulled pork, lettuce, pico de gallo, jalapeños, homemade cheese sauce, & sour cream.

Bavarian Pretzel Sticks (3)

Served with homemade beer cheese.

Fried Fresh Mozzarella (3)

Served with marinara sauce.

Nashville Chicken Sandwich

Breaded chicken cutlet dipped in a spicy oil, with lettuce, pickles, & crack sauce served on a garlic brioche roll.

French Dip

Homemade warm roast beef on a garlic hero served with au jus. Add cheese for an additional charge.

Turkey Club

Served on 3 slices of toast with bacon, lettuce, tomato, & mayo.

Cubano

Pulled pork, grilled ham, melted Swiss, pickles, & sriracha honey mustard on a pressed garlic hero.

Grilled Chicken Pesto

Melted fresh mozzarella, arugula, & red pepper pesto on a garlic hero.

Sliced Steak Hero

With melted American cheese & fried onions on a garlic hero.

Chicken Cordon Bleu

Grilled or fried chicken topped with grilled ham, melted Swiss, & honey mustard on a garlic brioche roll.

Chicken Claim

Marinated grilled chicken, with melted American cheese & fried onions on a garlic hero.

Sliced Steak Special

With arugula, shaved Parmesan, & creamy horseradish sauce.

Sun-dried Chicken Hero

Marinated grilled chicken, melted fresh mozzarella, & sun-dried tomatoes on a garlic hero.

Chicken Cutlet Club

Served on a garlic brioche roll with bacon, lettuce, tomato, & mayo.

Portobello Mushroom Sandwich

Topped with fresh melted mozzarella & bruschetta on a garlic brioche roll.

Blt

Bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo served on your choice of white, wheat or rye toast.

Buffalo Chicken

With melted mozzarella cheese on a garlic brioche roll.

Corned Beef Or Pastrami Reuben

Topped with sauerkraut, homemade russian dressing, & melted swiss on grilled rye.

Chicken Or Meatball Parm

With marinara sauce & melted mozzarella cheese on a garlic hero. Shrimp Parm for an additional charge.

Pulled Pork Hero

With coleslaw & pickles on a garlic hero.

Italian Combo

Ham, Genoa salami, pepperoni and provolone cheese with lettuce, tomatoe, onion and oil and vinegar on a hero

Roast Beef Hero

Homemade roast beef with provolone, lettuce, tomato and mayo

Turkey Hero

Turkey and American on a hero with lettuce, tomato and mayo

Grilled Cheese

Add bacon & tomato, ham or Taylor ham for an additional charge.

Ny Fish Sandwich

Homemade beer-battered swai fillet with arugula, pickles, & tartar sauce on a garlic brioche roll.

Sutter's Mill Burger

Half-pound ground mix sirloin, cooked the way you like!

Sutter's Double Smashburger

Double pressed patty topped with fried onions, melted American cheese, bacon, pickles, & crack sauce.

Pulled Pork Sliders (3)

Cheeseburger Sliders (3)

Turkey Burger Or Veggie Burger

Turkey or veggie patty options, served on a bun.

2 Hot Dogs

Served with French fries. Add sauerkraut or chili & cheese for an additional charge.

Hamburger Sliders (3)

Diet Burger

No bun, served with small salad & your choice of dressing.

California Burger

Sutter's Mill burger with avocado.

Beyond Vegan Burger

Sliced Steak Sliders (3)

With crumbled blue cheese.

Mac N Cheese

With homemade cheese sauce. add bacon or pulled pork for an additional charge.

Chicken Fingers

Add french fries for an additional charge.

Cheeseburger

Kids' cheeseburger with a choice of cola, diet cola, or lemon-lime drink.

Hamburger

Hamburger served with choice of cola, diet cola, or lemon-lime drink.

Pasta With Butter Or Marinara

Pasta served with choice of butter or marinara sauce. Includes drink option: cola, diet cola, or lemon-lime.

Grilled Cheese

Add bacon & tomato, ham or taylor ham for an additional charge.

Hot Dog (1)

Hot dog served with choice of cola, diet cola, or lemon-lime drink.

Wedge Salad

Wedge of romaine lettuce with bacon, tomato, & crumbled blue cheese.

Caesar Salad

Tossed in a creamy homemade Caesar dressing with grated & shaved Parmesan & croutons.

Cobb Salad

Grilled chicken, shredded Cheddar or jack cheese, tomato, cucumber, bacon, hard boiled egg, & avocado.

Taco Salad

Served in a tortilla shell with taco meat, shredded lettuce, pico de gallo, shredded cheese, black beans, cucumber, & guacamole.

Crock Of Chili

With cheese & onion. Make it a bowl! For an additional charge.

French Onion Soup

Tortellini En Brodo

Served with French bread.

Chef Salad

Turkey, ham, and American & Swiss over mixed greens with roasted peppers, cucumbers, tomatoes, red onion, kalamata olives, & hard boiled egg.

Tuscany Salad

Fresh mozzarella, sun-dried tomatoes, portobello mushroom, beets, & green olives over mixed field greens.

Garden Salad

Mixed field greens, tomatoes, cucumber, roasted peppers, red onion, & kalamata olives.

Soup Of The Day

Make it a bowl for an additional charge.

Lobster & Shrimp Mac N Cheese

Lobster & shrimp mixed into creamy macaroni cheese. Optional cocktail or tartar sauce.

Shrimp Basket

Fried shrimp, served with choice of cocktail or tartar sauce.

Fish N Chips

Fried beer-battered cod & fries.

Seared Ahi Tuna Steak

Served with arugula, red onion, cucumber, pumpkin seeds, & topped with sun-dried tomato vinaigrette.

Pan-seared Salmon

Served with rice & vegetable (plain, ginger teriyaki or honey mustard).

Seafood Basket

Fried beer-battered cod, fried shrimp, & fried clams.

Clam Basket

Clams fried in a light batter, served with a choice of cocktail or tartar sauce.

Baja Fish Tacos (choice Of Beer-battered Cod Or Shrimp)

Served on 3 soft shell corn tortillas with lettuce, pico de gallo, white sauce, & cajun seasoning.

Chicken Quesadilla

With grilled or pulled chicken, pico de gallo, salsa, & sour cream.

California Taco Platter

Quesadilla style taco with taco meat, lettuce, & pico de gallo served with chili & chips.

Cheese Quesadilla

Served with salsa & sour cream.

Adobo Smoked Churrasco

8 oz smoked NY strip steak char-grilled topped with a red wine glaze over arugula salad with blue cheese crumbles, red onion, & cucumber tossed in a balsamic vinaigrette.

Mac N Cheese

With homemade cheese sauce. Add bacon or pulled pork for an additional charge.

Half Roasted Chicken

Make it jerk chicken for an additional charge.

Chicken

Francaise, Marsala or parmigiana.

Half Rack Of Bbq Ribs

Add fried shrimp for an additional charge.

New York Grill Platter

Quarter chicken, 4 oz sirloin, chorizo, & guacamole.

Surf & Turf

8 oz char-grilled strip steak & 7 oz lobster tail.

Penne Pasta

With marinara and your choice of bolognese or meatballs.

8 Ounce Ribeye

8 ounce ribeye served with choice of salad (various dressings available) or side of potato, rice, or penne pasta.

Eggplant Parm Towers

With mozzarella cheese & marinara sauce served with penne pasta.

Penne Ala Vodka

Add chicken for an additional charge.

Classic Ny Strip Steak

8 oz char grilled steak.

Hot Open Turkey

Served over bread with gravy.